Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
While I'm very happy with my N9, I do have huge problems with SIP-telephony over Wifi.
My N900 had accepted wifi bugs, making serious SIP-telephony over Wifi impossible (stuttering, channel loss), I was hoping that the N9 would have reached the same quality as my old Symbian-based E51. The N9 is more useable than the N900 for SIP-telephony over Wifi I use a AVM Fritzbox 7170 for years and recently tried a D-Link DIR-645. Using the Fritzbox I often get package loss and general non-ideal voice quality, and always missing the first missing seconds of the talk, using the DIR-645 I've got a better over-all quality, but frequent complete connection dropout, especially when answering a call. Anyone here who has a setup where error-free serious SIP-over-Wifi telephony is working with the N9? Which equipment do you use, which Wifi channels etc.? ATM I'm considering to revive my E51 and degrade the N9 to a toy. :-( |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
The key to VOIP is QOS.
I got a couple of Linksys E3000, 1 Linksys WRT54GS v1.1 and a Cisco E4200v1 all using Tomato firmware (Toastman builds) and utilizing QOS So far everything is working great without any echo/delays over wifi and 3.5G |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
I too find telephony over WLAN with my FB 7270 next to unusable :( Can't even use 11n, in which case WLAN-connection breaks from time to time.
It seems as if power saving is a notch too high. Whenever there's no more data to stream for a (very) short while, the connection seems to back off. Pinging the router from the N9: Code:
64 bytes from 192.168.200.1: seq=9 ttl=64 time=195.648 ms Unfortunately I don't know how to disable power management, to see if that indeed is the case. So I can only confirm the problem. |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
There are other threads about wifi problems that you might want to search for.
What I did so far to be able to use SIP is to change my FB's (7270) wifi settings to 802.11b+g (disabling n) what helped a lot with lost connections. Both, ssh and SIP are usable since then. Concerning the ping latency, there was a hint to install wireless-tools and turn off wlan0's power managment (iwconfig wlan0 power off). This results in ping times of 1 ms but when the phone turns idle, something turns on power management, again. So that is not really a solution... Hope, that helps. |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
Quote:
Seriously, if you want real VOIP, get a REAL stuff, ie Linksys or better Cisco |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
Quote:
Digging in an iwconfig manual I saw a timeout-option. Code:
/sbin/iwconfig wlan0 power timeout 2 I can't test full duplex SIP right now, but calling the voice mail box worked well :) |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
BTW the connection speed may also depend on other wifi APs / network activity in your neighbourhood.
Check used channels in your area. Don't forget that only 1, 6 and 11 are really independent, all others skirt into the neighbouring channels, i.e. if your neighbour has his AP on channel 4, you should be on 9 or higher. BTW WiFi as a system deals better with collisions on the same channel (slot time sharing required) than on adjacent channels (noise/disturbance, bad reception at all times). That's why Bluetooth is a major disturbance to Wifi, quick channel hopping, so mostly a signal-to-noise degradation for the Wifi link. So if your neighbours are on 1, 6 and 11, best go on 1, 6, and 11 too, unless their link signal is weak, so your signal can just drown it, then go on an adjacent channel - your stronger signal / link should not be impacted much. Disclaimer: this that and the other from putting bits and pieces together - I'm not an RF engineer. |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
Thanks to everyone for the very detailed information. I'll try playing around with the wireless-tools and also try get hold of one this cisco-routers.
|
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
I've installed PR1.2 (full flash, clean device). Wow. Ping-times are now 5ms-10ms without further configuration. Browsing by wifi now feels very much more snappier than ever before. No more weird delays.
This might all be due to my FB7270 router, but given the clear fact it now works much better I'd say it was de N9's software as well. Haven't tried SIP, but this sure is promising. |
Re: Reliable Wifi-Access Point for N9 Sip Telephony
Quote:
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 19:30. |
vBulletin® Version 3.8.8