maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91305)

linuxovod 2013-09-07 10:00

Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Trying to find more powerful n900 successor I got used Motorola DROID 4 and spent some time with it. Found that hardware is almost perfect for my needs and have many common things with (or is inspired by) n900 - same sliding mechanism, same multicolor led on the same place etc. Keyboard is even better then E7 or N950 and has 5 (!) rows. There is TI OMAP 4430 2x1.2 CPU, 1G RAM (full specs on http://www.gsmarena.com/motorola_droid_4_xt894-4418.php). But Android OS is a nightmare.

bingomion 2013-09-07 12:10

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
my girlfriend has one!! I think the same everytime i see it!
But it doesn't have the fm/ir tx nor 32g stylus etc etc..
But very big keyboard.... Bigger screen too.
Shame its got android... Very slow!!

I gues its impossible because of the closed chips.


.
Quote:

Originally Posted by linuxovod (Post 1372661)
Trying to find more powerful n900 successor I got used Motorola DROID 4 and spent some time with it. Found that hardware is almost perfect for my needs and have many common things with (or is inspired by) n900 - same sliding mechanism, same multicolor led on the same place etc. Keyboard is even better then E7 or N950 and has 5 (!) rows. There is TI OMAP 4430 2x1.2 CPU, 1G RAM (full specs on http://www.gsmarena.com/motorola_droid_4_xt894-4418.php). But Android OS is a nightmare.


Flash-A-Holic 2016-09-24 10:19

The real successor of Nokia N900 - Droid 4 with Sailfish
 
EDIT: Finally this is real :):
This is so obvious! Why isn't this happened already? :eek:

Device: N900 --> N950 --> Droid 4
OS: Maemo --> MeeGo --> Sailfish
CPU (TI OMAP): 3430 --> 3630 --> 4430
Keyboard: 3 row --> 4 row --> 5 row

Yes, there is (still) things going on with Neo900. There is Jolla Phone with TOHKB. But why struggle with complicated solutions when we have cheap and hasslefree answer just around the corner?

Motorola Droid 4 is the real successor of Nokia N900 in every viewpoint. It even has Texas Instruments CPU like almost every Nokia phone before Windows Phone Era. The only missing piece is operating system (OS). But we already have the answer: Sailfish OS. Droid 4 has steady CyanogenMod builds so porting Sailfish shouldn't be problem (or is it :confused:)?

I know there is already pretty good Sailfish port for another "modern" qwerty phone, also made by Motorola, Photon Q. However it is lacking a SIM card slot and 3G band for Europe. And when you really think about it Photon Q is not the real N900 successor. It doesn't have great story behind it like Droid 4 does. One of the reasons why MeeGo died out was the lack of 4G support on OMAP 3 chips (The story of Nokia MeeGo). Nokia was losing the market on US and they thought that 4G was necessary. Nokia ended up to ditch TI which eventually led to end of both Nokia and TI (sort of). Ironically Droid 4 was released only in the US market with 4G (LTE) support.

So why to port Sailfish OS to Droid 4?
  • The Story behind it
  • Updated "modern" hardware (it even has Qi wireless charging and HDMI port)
  • Droid 4 already exist and you can buy it cheap from ebay right now!
  • Only software development needed
  • The real successor of Nokia N900

PS: There was some development going on couple years ago ([Q] Sailfish OS port for Droid 4). But I believe it should be easier this time as there is more devices with Sailfish now.

So let's make this real:
https://s15.postimg.org/f5b9djjcp/n9...ilfish_img.jpg

mp107 2016-09-24 11:28

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Some time ago I was looking for some newer Android smartphone with hardware keyboard (with SailfishOS porting in mind).

After few weeks of thoughts and analysis I decided finally to Motorola Droid 4 due to:
* SIM slot by default (unlike Photon Q)
* better 3G support in Europe (UMTS900 is not available in Photon Q)
* quite good support of CyanogenMod
* FM radio
* easier available in Poland than Photon Q
* Safestrap allows to have more than one ROM installed at once so the device might be used as a daily driver and to development/porting at the same time

I am also interested in porting (or at least some testing) Sailfish OS for Droid 4.
Unfortunately, I suppose I haven't got enough knowledge/skills to do it on my own. But I've got a plan to try.

r0kk3rz 2016-09-24 14:56

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mp107 (Post 1515515)
I am also interested in porting (or at least some testing) Sailfish OS for Droid 4.
Unfortunately, I suppose I haven't got enough knowledge/skills to do it on my own. But I've got a plan to try.

Good News! The guys in #sailfishos-porters on irc.freenode.net are quite active and really helpful, so even if you're the only one with this specific device you certainly aren't alone in your porting quest.

Flash-A-Holic 2016-09-24 17:03

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mp107 (Post 1515515)
I am also interested in porting (or at least some testing) Sailfish OS for Droid 4.
Unfortunately, I suppose I haven't got enough knowledge/skills to do it on my own. But I've got a plan to try.

Well that makes two of us. I have Droid 4 with CM13 and it is running just fine. However I think that Sailfish OS has to be ported to Droid 4. This story deserves it.

I'm an industrial engineering and management student and I have lot's of studying this year. I have completed only one programming course (python) so I'm not talented at all on developing. Even so I'm going to set up linux PC (once again) next week and start reading Hardware Adaptation Development Kit. Because the lack of skills and time don't expect anything from me. Even if I'm able to build something I think that it is impossible to me narrow down bugs and fix them.

But here is something to dream about. (It is just a theme):
https://s17.postimg.org/zd8wuab9p/DSC04475.jpg
EDIT: No more just a theme ;)
http://i.imgur.com/pgtp1EK.jpg

mp107 2016-09-24 17:39

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Not only two of us. ;)
There was at least one more person who at least tried to port SailfishOS to Droid4 (nick: klopsi-sdk): http://www.merproject.org/logs/%23sa...01-19.log.html

Flash-A-Holic 2016-09-25 05:38

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Seems that Klopsi managed to build something (2015-02-05):
  • klopsi-u3: so far i managed to build sailfish OS and boot into it on the device
  • klopsi-u3: and telnet and ssh to it
  • klopsi-u3: no screen working, no keyboard working, no gui
  • klopsi-u3: no camera, gps, wlan
But he was not able to build working build (2015-06-03):
  • klopsi-u3: i just want sailfish on my droid 4
  • zhxt: try to build one :)
  • klopsi-u3: i did
  • klopsi-u3: i tried porting to droid 4 but failed
  • klopsi-u3: nothing worked
  • klopsi-u3: except for the vibration driver
  • klopsi-u3: i could make the phone vibrate
  • klopsi-u3: if anybody wants to try porting to the droid 4 i will send you a phone
There was also antranigv considering porting but I guess he never actually started (2015-02-05):
  • antranigv: well, now I hope I'll buy droid 4, then port Jolla
  • antranigv: Sailfish I mean
  • antranigv: I ordered a Droid 4 :) is that good news?

I'm starting to despair since those guys were not able to succeed. However there is hope since Galaxy Nexus (maguro) has Salfish build (alpha) and similar hardware than Droid 4.

Anyway I'm going to set up Linux tomorrow and check what I can do. But we are going to need help!

m4r0v3r 2016-09-25 08:52

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
atm cm13 has issues with sfos.

mp107 2016-09-25 09:15

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
I would opt for using CM11 as the base for porting, like in the HADK documentation.
Or CM10.x as in the mentioned previous attempts.

m4r0v3r 2016-09-25 11:36

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
cm12 would be best, its the one thats been used on the N5 and thats been very stable,

r0kk3rz 2016-09-25 12:45

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
you might be better off with CM12 actually, thats what the majority of ports are based off these days and so the CM tree has had a lot of patches to it for common issues.

Flash-A-Holic 2016-09-25 16:20

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by r0kk3rz (Post 1515580)
you might be better off with CM12 actually, thats what the majority of ports are based off these days and so the CM tree has had a lot of patches to it for common issues.

Quote:

Originally Posted by m4r0v3r (Post 1515579)
cm12 would be best, its the one thats been used on the N5 and thats been very stable,

Ninja edit:
So is the best option CM12.1 or CM12? I was thinking that CM11 would be best. But I guess you guys know better than me. (I don't see why to try with CM10.x since Klopsi already tried with it).

r0kk3rz 2016-09-25 17:27

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flash-A-Holic (Post 1515585)
Ninja edit:
So is the best option CM12.1 or CM12? I was thinking that CM11 would be best. But I guess you guys know better than me. (I don't see why to try with CM10.x since Klopsi already tried with it).

CM12.1 sorry, I don't think we have a hybris branch for CM12 anyway. It's not that hard to try both and see what works best, ideally you should use the most bug free version.

Don't worry so much about what was tried before, the HADK has progressed so things that were broken might be ok now.

Be aware that you will likely need to spend a fair bit of time getting all the different bits working, its not a case of just running through the HADK and having everything magically just work.

m4r0v3r 2016-09-25 19:01

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
its an interesting device tbh, if i can find one cheap i may get it

Flash-A-Holic 2016-09-26 16:11

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by r0kk3rz (Post 1515589)
Be aware that you will likely need to spend a fair bit of time getting all the different bits working, its not a case of just running through the HADK and having everything magically just work.

I know that and that is why we need help!

Quote:

Originally Posted by m4r0v3r (Post 1515593)
its an interesting device tbh, if i can find one cheap i may get it

Excellent! :)

Update: Ubuntu is up! Next to set up SDK :cool:

t-b 2016-10-06 19:15

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Anyone tried to install Debian Chroot on this phone? Or something similar?

Flash-A-Holic 2016-10-16 05:30

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by t-b (Post 1516307)
Anyone tried to install Debian Chroot on this phone? Or something similar?

No, I haven't. Have you tried?

Flash-A-Holic 2017-01-30 07:18

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
This might be interesting: [Porting] Wayland, libhybris. Devs needed! (Plasma Mobile, Mer, Sailfish OS..)

Quote:

Originally Posted by tmlind
OK got the LCD console working last night That's with omapdrm with most of the kernel.org sre/linux-n900.git patches in n950-display branch. I still have some pixelclock getting miscalculated issues and need to clean up things, but then should be able to post a test branch to play with. No idea what it might take to get the rest of the accelerated graphics going but hopefully others people can take it from there.


tmlind 2017-02-04 21:38

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flash-A-Holic (Post 1522609)

Hi all it's been a while :) I just posted some droid 4 WIP patches against current Linux next:
http://muru.com/linux/d4/

Flash-A-Holic 2017-02-07 08:06

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tmlind (Post 1522847)
Hi all it's been a while :) I just posted some droid 4 WIP patches against current Linux next:
http://muru.com/linux/d4/

Amazing work :eek:! I really hope that someone talented person can help you :).

mp107 2017-03-21 12:13

Re: Motorola droid 4 XT894 keyboard device
 
There is also an interesting development related to Motorola Droid 4 and Linux kernel here:
http://elektranox.org/droid4/

I've found it linked on http://muru.com/linux/d4/.


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:04.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8