maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N9 / N950 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=51)
-   -   Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=81550)

Tarl 2012-01-12 16:24

Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Does anyone know if the Nokia N9 is supporting EAP-sim ?

Thanks

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensi...otocol#EAP-SIM

P@t 2012-01-12 20:28

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Related to Free Mobile in France?
Am interested too but I fear that this is not possible as I do not see any sort of option related to it in the N9 parameters...

Tarl 2012-01-12 20:49

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Yes of course !

But i don't think it's a real option that need to be activated just supported like wifi or bluetooth.... Hope so by the way

P@t 2012-01-13 17:14

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
When I say option, I mean that when you create a new internet connection, you can specify what sort of security it has: you can select EAP-TLS EAP-TTLS... but I do not see EAP-SIM... that is why I am skeptical :(

Tarl 2012-01-13 18:46

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Ok so let's try something else ?

Does anyone know how to add this protocol in a Nokia N9 ??

P@t 2012-01-16 10:23

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
http://www.freemobileasso.com/discus...e-avec-eap-sim
seems to provide some infos...
May be that should come to https://harmattan-bugs.nokia.com/ as an enhancement request?!

clovis86 2012-01-16 10:31

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
done :)

https://harmattan-bugs.nokia.com/show_bug.cgi?id=645

Tarl 2012-01-16 11:04

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Comment and vote !

bouznak 2012-01-17 13:13

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tarl (Post 1151234)
Comment and vote !

Done !

I hope that works.

clovis86 2012-01-17 13:25

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
on pourrait presque parler en Français içi ...

y'a un peu que nous que ca intéresse ...; :D

P@t 2012-01-17 13:33

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Some discussion today on that
http://mg.pov.lt/harmattan-irclog/%2...01-17.log.html

Apparently there is a question on what is EAPD and a comment on wpa_supplicant not being available on HARM ...

I hope that Nokia provides some input, at least indicating directions on how to add it! But I fear that if this is tricky, it will not be part of PR1.2 which is currently being finalised...

bouznak 2012-01-17 17:09

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by clovis86 (Post 1151831)
on pourrait presque parler en Français içi ...

y'a un peu que nous que ca intéresse ...; :D

Oui en effet. Je crois qu'à part la Suisse et peut-être la Belgique, peu de pays ont des opérateurs mettant en avant cette fonctionnalité. Apparemment on n'est pas rendus pour l'avoir...

Tarl 2012-01-17 19:31

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Presque ;)

turbovomit 2012-01-17 20:48

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Et pour le n900 ?
Est-ce qu'il est compatible ?
J'attends ma carte sim de chez Free...

ça fait bizarre d'écrire français ici...
:)

P@t 2012-01-18 12:21

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
We should probably keep discussing in English to allow for more people to understand our needs and to get possibly more help?

About the N900, apparently eap-sim is not supported either... And I have no idea if the same sort of solution can be applied to both phones (probably yes as they share the same maemo roots?!)

turbovomit 2012-01-18 18:23

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by P@t (Post 1152306)
About the N900, apparently eap-sim is not supported either... And I have no idea if the same sort of solution can be applied to both phones (probably yes as they share the same maemo roots?!)


So, does the n900 will work with an eap-sim (data, call, wifi) and just don't use free hotspot ?
Or i will not be able to make calls at all ?

colin.stephane 2012-01-19 07:17

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi all,

On my side here is what I understand :

- Actually I don't need 'EAP-SIM authentication' to be able to use Freewifi Hotspots from my N900 (not already tested with my N9 but I don't see any restrictions that can block the same process).
- By the way, without 'EAP-SIM authentication' I have to connect to the open Freewifi Hotspot near me, then, after that, go to the default captive web site to enter my authentication credentials.
- Then I'm able to use the Freewifi Hotpsot as usual.
- If I understand properly 'EAP-SIM authentication', whenever the device connect to the Freewifi Hotspot, then the authentication is automatically pushed, avoiding the phase to use the captive web site to manually entering credentials ...

- I think if the device doesn't support 'EAP-SIM authentication', then we fall back to entering the credentials manually using the old method (captive web site).

Hope it help ...

www.rzr.online.fr 2012-01-19 08:12

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi,

I have a mobile.free.fr SIM card and n950
how can I help ?



note that
wget url?login=&passwd=
can do the job i use it
but is there a way to do that automagickaly w/ a hook on a dbus event ?

TeHeR 2012-01-23 13:02

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi,

I think SIM-EAP is better than that.

Of course it allow authentication as you mention it. But as I understand, it also allow to use the Wifi automatically instead of your 3G data connection.

So man should have better transfer rate and economize your data quota.

Quote:

Originally Posted by colin.stephane (Post 1152653)
Hi all,

On my side here is what I understand :

- Actually I don't need 'EAP-SIM authentication' to be able to use Freewifi Hotspots from my N900 (not already tested with my N9 but I don't see any restrictions that can block the same process).
- By the way, without 'EAP-SIM authentication' I have to connect to the open Freewifi Hotspot near me, then, after that, go to the default captive web site to enter my authentication credentials.
- Then I'm able to use the Freewifi Hotpsot as usual.
- If I understand properly 'EAP-SIM authentication', whenever the device connect to the Freewifi Hotspot, then the authentication is automatically pushed, avoiding the phase to use the captive web site to manually entering credentials ...

- I think if the device doesn't support 'EAP-SIM authentication', then we fall back to entering the credentials manually using the old method (captive web site).

Hope it help ...


Hec 2012-01-23 15:32

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
I saw that the N900 supports EAP protocol which isn't EAP-SIM but could be close. I'll be joining Free Mobile on thursday (If I receive my sim card soon enough :)) and start tests right away.

Meanwhile many Free techies still own a N900 as a pro phone. I hope some Free personnal could be helping about a solution if any.

tnz 2012-02-02 10:17

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
@Hec : Install AutoFreeWifi to connect on FreeWifi networks. But, for this, you must have a Freebox and a FreeWifi ID.

If you've got FreeMobile only, I'm afraid you won't have any chance to connect on FreeWifi with the N900.

Tarl 2012-04-19 10:17

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Ok so Free launch the EAP sim support today... still not available for the Nokia N9... I think it may have a solution because the N9 already support the EAP protocol for wifi the only thing missing is the sim authentification ability...

Hope to see it in PR 1.3 or in an alternative app ;)

bob_bipbip 2012-04-19 18:58

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
c'est bizarre car normalement, swisscom fait de l'eapsim, et d'apres ce que j'ai entendu, pas de soucis avec. est ce aue la rom suisse aurai quelque chose de particulier???

verrnum 2012-04-20 09:05

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi Everybody,

i am interesting by eap-sim support too according to free mobile deployment.

2 bugs tracking was created but none delivery seems to be planned...

Quote:

"Not planned for 1.2 - unresourced and lacking required network infrastructure
for dev and testing. "
https://bugs.meego.com/show_bug.cgi?id=5581#c0
https://bugs.meego.com/show_bug.cgi?id=7963

Our only chance is the existing of a french meego developer using free mobile network :(

Best Regards

onil 2012-04-23 11:50

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi,
I ttried to connect to a Free eap-sim enabled mobile hotspot with my n900 this week-end. It did'nt work.:mad:
However, I found this sentence in maemo wiki:
Quote:

As a special case, controlling the EAP-SIM authentication using the SIM Access Profile
at: http://http://wiki.maemo.org/Documen...o_Connectivity.

Does someone know if this means EAP-SIM is implemented but not available to the user beacause of lacking GUI/sufficient testing?
As libicd-network-eap is closed source I think only some nokian can tell us more about this.
It would be great if there is an implementation available at least through dbus.

I also found some developer wrote a libicd plugin called libicd-network-wpa which allows to manage connections through wpa-supplicant (which has support for EAP-SIM). I will try to dig further.
Bye!

rainisto 2012-04-23 12:36

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
EAP-SIM has _not_ been implemented, so its not just UI missing.

And even if you try to recompile N900 libicd-network-wpa, you will notice that javispedros wpasupplicant is compiled without CONFIG_EAP_SIM, so there is no support currently in that way either.

Summa summarum EAP-SIM is not supported and most likely will never be supported, unless you code everything yourself.

P@t 2012-04-23 12:46

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
sad but clear enough...
Thanks a lot anyway for that info. So the chance has suddenly dropped to some number close to 0% :(
I will survive anyway ;)

nemric 2012-12-10 16:31

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi,

For my first post i'd like to know if someone did try to write :

network={
ssid="FreeWifi_secure"
key_mgmt=WPA-EAP IEEE8021X
eap=SIM
priority=5
}

in wpa_supplicant.conf ?

I've found some code here : http://gitorious.org/harmattan-extra-packages
you can download sources here : http://gitorious.org/harmattan-extra...commits/debian

So there are codes to manage eap sim authentication (eap_sim.c, eap-methods.c, ...)
Don't know which version of wpa_supplicant is installed and how to update or modifiy it

I'll receive my n9 in a few weeks, I'll try it ASAP ...

nemric 2012-12-27 10:19

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
For my last post :
Sorry, i won't be able to test it ... i'm so desapointed because of 802.11n hardware problem (only works when screen is locked :eek: )
I send N9 back to vendor ... will stay with E72 ...

verrnum 2012-12-28 12:42

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Hi,

Thanks for your work.

I am interesting by the subject even if i don't have Free mobile as ISP.

Regards

Shadow_Max 2015-01-25 12:41

Re: Nokia N9 Meego & EAP-Sim
 
Where is locate wpa_supplicant.conf ? i would like to try it


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:12.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8