maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Community (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=90344)

GeneralAntilles 2013-06-04 00:08

Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
Update (2013-06-18): The questionnaire thread is up.

The Hildon Foundation Board of Directors election will, hopefully, be coming up in a few weeks. Full disclosure: I've nominated myself to be a candidate in those elections.

I'd like to compile a list of questions that we'd be interesting in seeing potential candidates answer.

Candidates should not answer these questions in this thread.

I'd like to see a list of questions compiled before we get any answers. Candidates can answer after the nomination period is over.

Here's what I've come up with so far:
  1. Where do you see maemo.org in 1 year? In 5 years?
  2. What do see you as the primary role for the Hildon Foundation Board of Directors?
  3. How do you envision the relationship between the Hildon Foundation Board of Directors and the Hildon Foundation Council/Maemo Community Council?
  4. Are you able to attend board meetings at least monthly?

Quote:

Originally Posted by reinob (Post 1349670)
Do you own a Maemo device? do you (regularly) use a Maemo device? Are you at all interested in Maemo and its community?

Quote:

Originally Posted by vivainio (Post 1352617)
What kind of collaboration do you expect to see from Nokia, to ensure survival of the most important assets?


joerg_rw 2013-06-04 00:15

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
[2013-06-04 02:15:04] <DocScrutinizer05> I'd probably rather ask "do you understand that the primary role of HiFo is to be community's *treasurer* and *accountant*? And that there's NO great _mission_ that HiFo should follow?"

...since HiFo doesn't even have the means nor the legitimation to follow such mission. If any great mission ever comes to existance, it will be born in the middle of maemo community, not in the heads of BoD during their dreams of changing the world. HiFo DOES NOT oversee and rule the community, it's community to oversee and rule HiFo, and it's community to decide any long term goal or project they want to pursue.
And now I notice I already slipped into Q#3 of above [relation MCC/HFC<->BoD]. Well that's easy to answer: MCC is community's proxy (and steward), BoD is community's treasurer. Defines it all, comprehensively. While HFC is the supervisory board of HiFo, which is why the both councils should (and will) get unified. Actually for 99.9% of us they never been two entities to start with.
OK, that's hardly a question now, it rather became a cover version of my application for past election

GeneralAntilles 2013-06-04 17:14

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joerg_rw (Post 1349350)
[2013-06-04 02:15:04] <DocScrutinizer05> I'd probably rather ask "do you understand that the primary role of HiFo is to be community's *treasurer* and *accountant*? And that there's NO great _mission_ that HiFo should follow?"

Now there's a question with an agenda. :P Let them answer question #2, and judge whether their opinion is compatible with yours based on that answer.

Quote:

Originally Posted by joerg_rw (Post 1349350)
...since HiFo doesn't even have the means nor the legitimation to follow such mission. If any great mission ever comes to existance, it will be born in the middle of maemo community, not in the heads of BoD during their dreams of changing the world. HiFo DOES NOT oversee and rule the community, it's community to oversee and rule HiFo, and it's community to decide any long term goal or project they want to pursue.
And now I notice I already slipped into Q#3 of above [relation MCC/HFC<->BoD]. Well that's easy to answer: MCC is community's proxy (and steward), BoD is community's treasurer. Defines it all, comprehensively. While HFC is the supervisory board of HiFo, which is why the both councils should (and will) get unified. Actually for 99.9% of us they never been two entities to start with.
OK, that's hardly a question now, it rather became a cover version of my application for past election

A topic for another, let's stick to questions for board candidates. ;)

reinob 2013-06-05 08:05

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
5. Do you own a Maemo device? do you (regularly) use a Maemo device? Are you at all interested in Maemo and its community?

GeneralAntilles 2013-06-05 15:11

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by reinob (Post 1349670)
5. Do you own a Maemo device? do you (regularly) use a Maemo device? Are you at all interested in Maemo and its community?

This is one I was considering, but had decided against because so many people have moved on to newer devices and platforms. Given recent history, though, it's probably more important than I'd like to believe.

The most important part, though, is the last bit. :D

reinob 2013-06-06 08:44

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 1349762)
This is one I was considering, but had decided against because so many people have moved on to newer devices and platforms.

I may be a bit "fundamentalist" here, but in my book, we're still the Maemo community (even though it's now called "Hildon") so people who don't care for Maemo should not run for Council, or Foundation, or any other place.

Quote:

Given recent history, though, it's probably more important than I'd like to believe.

The most important part, though, is the last bit. :D
Agreed. But again, for the last bit to be true I would expect at least knowledge and regular use of a Maemo device.

It's not like we need "independent" consultants or anything. We're just a bunch of people interested in Maemo and attempting to keep the infrastructure running.

Please no master plans, no abstractions. Just Maemo, thank you.

vivainio 2013-06-17 07:20

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
I'm a bit late to this to this party, but one question I'd like to see answered:

What kind of collaboration do you expect to see from Nokia, to ensure survival of the most important assets?

GeneralAntilles 2013-06-17 23:26

Re: Questions for Hildon Foundation Board candidates
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vivainio (Post 1352617)
What kind of collaboration do you expect to see from Nokia, to ensure survival of the most important assets?

Good question!

OK, I think I'll finalize the list later tonight or sometime tomorrow and post a new thread for candidates to respond in. If anyone has any more questions, now's the time to post them.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:26.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8