View Single Post
YoDude's Avatar
Posts: 2,869 | Thanked: 1,784 times | Joined on Feb 2007 @ Po' Bo'. PA
#16
Originally Posted by sjgadsby View Post
I hadn't run any actual speed tests, believe it or not, and my only previous cellular data experience has been with my N800 & N810 tethered to a Boost iDEN phone. I'm probably easily impressed, but EDGE is a wonderful improvement.

I'm at home right now, in a rural area with weak signal on every network. My N900 shows 2.5G and two bars, the fewest I get anywhere. In this same spot, my iDEN phone is lucky just to escape "No Service"-land for a few seconds. MobileSpeedTest tells me AT&T EDGE is only turning out 28 kbps here, but even that is two to three times better than the best I ever achieved anywhere with iDEN*, and I know I get better on EDGE elsewhere.



Heh. In a little more than a month, I've used less than 10 MB. I've WiFi at home, WiFi at work, and only a six minute drive in between. As much as I like Internet radio, it's not worth the setting up the FM transmitter.

I don't think I make for a good example of how much data anyone else might burn through in a month.



Yes, something along those lines has been a concern for me after the unlimited Internet of Boost. Worst case though, AT&T can only take what remains of the $110 credit in my account and then turn my service off. They don't even have a credit card number to "accidentally" charge.

Trust me, I do not trust AT&T. I've had nothing but horrible experiences with both their cellular and long distance divisions in the past, so I'm not thrilled to be giving them money now. T-Mobile somehow managed to develop a PAYG system that makes them an even less attractive though. I keep waiting for them to explain it has been a little joke they've been playing on the U.S.



Shh! Not so loud! Those tabloid reporters are everywhere.


* Darn you, Sprint, for killing WiDEN. My phone could have been a great modem. It could have been a contender!
Excellent...

... N800 & N810 tethered to a .... iDEN phone. Check!

... 28 kbps that is two to three times better. Check!

... WiFi at home. Check!

... Semi rural Pennsylvania. Check!

... and even if I manage to use 10 times what you use in a month, after initial set up charges, it would still only be $23.98

... ding, ding, ding. I think we have a winner!

If the cheapest from T-mo is the $39.99 plan I pointed to earlier, the cost of 3G would be at least $16.01 a month more.

At close to $200 more per year for 3G, and only if the plan I pointed to works (if not, much higher), I think I can live with 2G.
__________________

SLN member # 009

Last edited by YoDude; 2009-12-05 at 03:05.