To the topic of ByLaws: The ByLaws were a community effort. I facilitated that effort, and did the manual work of piecing in things that were not in the original draft. Things like even having elections, instead of self-appointment, and having a Council, just to name two examples.

For what it's worth, Rob was acting as legal council at the time. He did have input a couple times. In particular the last version has at least one change he noted was legally required after he reviewed it.

As for the "broken rule" issue, can you clarify what rule you believe has been broken?