View Single Post
Posts: 4 | Thanked: 8 times | Joined on May 2007 @ Espoo, Finland
#8
Originally Posted by qgil View Post
It's been a while that I have been wondering about the mid term usefulness of http://garage.maemo.org . It made a lot of sense when it started in 2005, but nowadays there is a variety of rock solid services providing all those services, only not in a single place.
Don't forget that granting upload privileges to extras happens through garage. It would take some effort to move this functionality elsewhere..

But how relevant is to have an ok-ish single place when with simple links you can have at reach free infrastructure like gitorious.org, transifex.net, wordpress.com, your closest bugzilla, etc?

The last garage project I created had as basically main purpose the obtention of a mailing list. I guess we could also have a default recommendation for project mailing lists.
Conclusion: http://gforge.org itself is not a simple beast to maintain, leave alone to customize, and the benefits nowadays are probably slim. So why not leaving it in pure maintenance mode, pointing developers to the current better alternatives instead of trying to add even more beef there?
GForge is not that bad to maintain. We have added quite a bit of new functionality there, we have the know-how.

There are couple of things which our garage offers for free unlike other providers:
  • possibility of running private projects
  • unlimited storage (for code, docs, etc)

However I agree with the maintenance mode proposal, but if there are some great ideas we can hack on GForge, no worries.
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to Ferenc Szekely For This Useful Post: