Reply
Thread Tools
Guest | Posts: n/a | Thanked: 0 times | Joined on
#131
This thread has shown me that there is a lot of incomplete options, but many more than I would have suspected.
 

The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to For This Useful Post:
Ken-Young's Avatar
Posts: 387 | Thanked: 1,700 times | Joined on Feb 2010 @ Cambridge, MA, USA
#132
Originally Posted by pythoneye2 View Post
[...]
If i consider your skillset
http://talk.maemo.org/showpost.php?p...2&postcount=83
and look at Orrery wiki and source code (looks nice) and your financial position i wonder how can they make you not succeed? dirty details please!
[...]
Thanks for the very kind words, but a shudder goes down my spine every time I hear someone has looked at my orrery code! I consider it to be a mess - very poor (actually, almost no) separation of the UI code from the calculations code, for example. There is also stuff in there that was intended to make performance tolerable for Openmoko phones, which does not make sense for more modern devices and should be stripped out.

Regarding your real question, I guess I've been both lazy and poorly informed. For example, I thought that Wayland would provide the sort of effortless X11 compatibility one gets on Mac OS X. It looks like that is not the case. The thing I personally need *most* is X11 server mode on my handheld, displaying for a remote client. It doesn't look to me like that's available either with SailfishOS or Ubuntu Touch. For those OSs it looks like X11 capability, at best, supports local X11 clients. And there are these little caveats like "input doesn't work", etc., which make a big difference to me. Using VNC is much more cumbersome than having a real X11 server, and some of the remote machines I work with are headless.

I guess my best course is to wait for Pyra. If both my n900s (and any neo900 that I get my hands on) die before Pyras ship, my best course might then be to try to get SailfishOS running on a Nexus 5 (or whatever is the best "supported" hardware at that time) and try to strip out Wayland and substitute X11.

The fragmentation of Linux display managers into X11, Surfaceflinger, Wayland and Mir is certainly a grim development. I know X11 is full of ancient cruft and providing full X11 server compatibility involves supporting crazy things like its old, ugly pixel fonts, but given Android's huge market share, I think Jolla and Ubuntu should have just gone with Surfaceflinger.

The real irony is that if Apple were to implement the X11 capability in iOS that they provide in Mac OS X, my best choice for managing remote Linux servers would be an iPhone!

Last edited by Ken-Young; 2016-01-11 at 03:32.
 

The Following 11 Users Say Thank You to Ken-Young For This Useful Post:
Guest | Posts: n/a | Thanked: 0 times | Joined on
#133
Originally Posted by Ken-Young View Post
The real irony is that if Apple were to implement the X11 capability in iOS that they provide in Mac OS X, my best choice for managing remote Linux servers would be an iPhone!
That is ironic but very interesting.
 

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to For This Useful Post:
Posts: 702 | Thanked: 2,059 times | Joined on Feb 2011 @ UK
#134
Originally Posted by Ken-Young View Post
The real irony is that if Apple were to implement the X11 capability in iOS that they provide in Mac OS X, my best choice for managing remote Linux servers would be an iPhone!
Apple haven't provided X11 support in OSX for some time now. The last X11.app was OSX 10.7.

It's now a separate open source project as XQuartz of which Apple do contribute to but it's pretty clear they don't think it's that important. There's no support for retina displays for instance.

The chances of them ever supporting iOS would be approaching zero.

IME it's never been that great on OSX even when they did support it fully. It was more of a hangover from NeXT.
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to aegis For This Useful Post:
Feathers McGraw's Avatar
Posts: 654 | Thanked: 2,368 times | Joined on Jul 2014 @ UK
#135
Originally Posted by aegis View Post
Apple haven't provided X11 support in OSX for some time now. The last X11.app was OSX 10.7.
Is this related to them dropping OpenGL? I've just started learning about it and was quite surprised to read that they don't support the newer OpenGL standards. Shame, because otherwise Qt + OpenGL would be a great way to develop apps that run nicely on all 3 platforms.
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Feathers McGraw For This Useful Post:
Ken-Young's Avatar
Posts: 387 | Thanked: 1,700 times | Joined on Feb 2010 @ Cambridge, MA, USA
#136
Originally Posted by aegis View Post
Apple haven't provided X11 support in OSX for some time now. The last X11.app was OSX 10.7.

It's now a separate open source project as XQuartz of which Apple do contribute to but it's pretty clear they don't think it's that important. There's no support for retina displays for instance.

The chances of them ever supporting iOS would be approaching zero.

IME it's never been that great on OSX even when they did support it fully. It was more of a hangover from NeXT.
I certainly didn't seriously think Apple would ever bring X11 support to iOS. I was just pointing out how ironic it is that X11-compatibility "just works" in Mac OS X, while X11 works poorly at best (after additional software is loaded, and scripts are written) under Wayland or Mir, despite official claims that these display managers would provide X11 compatibility.

I was unaware Mac OS X did not support X11 on retina displays. I'd better take care of my ageing Macbook!
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to Ken-Young For This Useful Post:
Posts: 702 | Thanked: 2,059 times | Joined on Feb 2011 @ UK
#137
Originally Posted by Feathers McGraw View Post
Is this related to them dropping OpenGL? I've just started learning about it and was quite surprised to read that they don't support the newer OpenGL standards. Shame, because otherwise Qt + OpenGL would be a great way to develop apps that run nicely on all 3 platforms.
I don't think it's related. They dropped X11 much earlier.

They'd rather you used Metal. It's available on iOS and OSX and although there's often significant performance reasons to use it over OpenGL, the upshot is you're then developing to an Apple only API and not supporting Android.

Originally Posted by Ken-Young
I was unaware Mac OS X did not support X11 on retina displays. I'd better take care of my ageing Macbook!
XQuartz pixel doubles rather than take advantage of the higher dpi. ie. it works but next to a Mac app on the same screen it looks like blurry bitmapped crap.

edit: I only know this because last week I needed the statistics package 'R' which is an X11 app on the Mac. I then realised I'd not installed X11 on my Mac since I bought it in 2012. I've used CDs more often.
 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to aegis For This Useful Post:
Posts: 110 | Thanked: 362 times | Joined on May 2014
#138
I still dont see why (the lowest common denominator)
running a "headless" X11 server running on your phone with a VNC display driver and a VNC input driver [which you locally connect to via a vnc client] shouldnot work.
It is not x11 or vnc it is: X11 via vnc.
Sure it is a overhead going through kind of framebuffer driver and local network but the VNC "last mile" gives you also input and display translation [from touchscreen to rightmouse click (+) drag and drop, zooming] which are sometimes needed for non fingerfriendly X11 applications.
[Or can you rebind the rightclick drag and drop gesture to shift + drag and drop on any open gui toolkit? Im hoping for emacs2020.]

This is done on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfMLzlki9XE but the connection vnc server to vnc client is over wifi and not locally.
[But it shouldnt be laggy anyway, except he has a very very very bad wifi connection]
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to pythoneye2 For This Useful Post:
Posts: 1,082 | Thanked: 1,235 times | Joined on Apr 2010
#139
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to railroadmaster For This Useful Post:
debernardis's Avatar
Posts: 2,142 | Thanked: 2,054 times | Joined on Dec 2006 @ Sicily
#140
Vnc to X on chroot on modern android devices isn't laggy at all. And, as I reported previously, X is available too without the need of vnc.
__________________
Ernesto de Bernardis

 

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to debernardis For This Useful Post:
Reply

Tags
f*ck apple, f*ck google, f*ck microsoft, gnu telephony, gnu/linux, linux deploy


 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:40.