Reply
Thread Tools
Posts: 477 | Thanked: 118 times | Joined on Dec 2005 @ Munich, Germany
#1
I would like to address the point made here and here


What I'm basically saying is that the incentive for Nokia to carry on with the tablets is ebbing away:

- Nokia tablet sales so far have been relatively small, certainly nowhere near Nokia's phone sales (which are about 400 million units a year)

- Nokia's tablets have continued to be obscure niche items for three years now

- The economy is crumbling, like most companies Nokia will probably have much less spare cash to play with

- Nokia's own touchscreen Symbian phones are hitting the shops in a few months time, with the first model due to launch at a relatively low price (about half that of the iPhone). It seems likely to sell well, with more advanced bigger-screen models due in 2009.

- The market for pocket-sized non-telephony devices is vanishing, and tiny compared to telephony devices

- Making Nokia Maemo touch phones is not the answer because they would be rivals to Nokia Symbian touch phones. Companies try to avoid developing rival product lines, because it duplicates costs while cannibalising sales.

- If Nokia is forced to choose between Maemo phones and Symbian phones, they're very likely to choose Symbian phones because these sell in much larger numbers (about 60 million a year) and have much more operator support.

- Another manufacturer making Maemo phones might work, but no other companies have shown any interest in making Maemo phones (and neither has Nokia really, apart from mobile data)

IMHO the only way Maemo can survive is if it changes radically into something that isn't pocket-sized. My suggestion is explained in the link above.

Maybe. Nobody can predict the future. But there is more to be said:

-Internet "tablets" are still a developing market. Apple, as a competitor, sells the iPod touch relatively well (it is an iPod, a gaming device and an internet tablet at the same time, however). Asus demonstrated with the EEEPC that a small form factor and cheap Internet device sells like hot cakes.

-Symbian is an aging OS and very difficult to program (you have to take care of things like garbage collection yourself, etc...). Apple (again) demonstrated with the iPhone and iPod touch that a modern OS with an easy to use programming environment together with a working distribution system is able to attract more programmers in a matter of months than Symbian has attracted in years. Nokia needs a new OS for more modern phones.

-the market for mobile Internet has been stagnating for years and has just started to take off lately with the iPhone.


Nokia has also announced a N900 with a sim slot. We don't know if they are going to change their mind before it is out, but at least they are working on the next model for the moment.

Last edited by Jerome; 2008-10-26 at 14:55.
 
Posts: 183 | Thanked: 77 times | Joined on Jul 2006 @ Mountain View, CA
#2
Originally Posted by Jerome View Post
IApple (again) demonstrated with the iPhone and iPod touch that a modern OS with an easy to use programming environment together with a working distribution system is able to attract more programmers in a matter of months than Symbian has attracted in years.
Just curious what you base this assertion on, in regards to the number of developers for each platform?

Nokia has also announced a N900 with a sim slot
Really? Where?
__________________
My insane ramblings are exactly that -- mine. Just because I work at Nokia doesn't mean I speak for the company.

Check out the Nokia Internet Tablet Video Converter: http://www.nokia.com/betalabs/videoconverter
 
Posts: 1,208 | Thanked: 1,028 times | Joined on Oct 2007
#3
Originally Posted by vbrilon View Post
Really? Where?
Nowhere, but they have said that next major software release will support 3G/HSPA data, so assumption is that next hw relesease will support cellular too
 
Posts: 183 | Thanked: 77 times | Joined on Jul 2006 @ Mountain View, CA
#4
Yeah but a software announcement is very different from "N900" announcement you stated. Just keeping the record straight.
__________________
My insane ramblings are exactly that -- mine. Just because I work at Nokia doesn't mean I speak for the company.

Check out the Nokia Internet Tablet Video Converter: http://www.nokia.com/betalabs/videoconverter
 
tso's Avatar
Posts: 4,783 | Thanked: 1,253 times | Joined on Aug 2007 @ norway
#5
Originally Posted by Jerome View Post
Apple (again) demonstrated with the iPhone and iPod touch that a modern OS with an easy to use programming environment together with a working distribution system is able to attract more programmers in a matter of months than Symbian has attracted in years.
im not so sure if it was the dev environment that pulled people over as much as the chance of getting those minutes of press coverage by supplying the "killer app" to the "killer device"...

btw, i think one pretty much need a mac to do iphone/touch develpment...

also, Qt recently got ported to symbian...
 
b-man's Avatar
Posts: 549 | Thanked: 502 times | Joined on Feb 2008 @ Bowling Green Ohio (united states)
#6
I know that this is a slightly off-topic and silly question but since Nokia is planning a fuew mager changes to the N900's hardware and software, do you think that both the N800 and N810 will be discontinued much like the N770 was when OS2007 came out? Since the N900 will likely have a more powerful prosesor and possibly a slightly different chipset allong with more powerful graphics (possibly OpenGL 2.0) and also a different camera.
__________________
I'm an advanced user and a bit of a modder.
----------------------------------------------
I am involved with Mer, Deblet, and NITdroid.
My ports/creations/hacks: GNOME (for Deblet), Cdeb2», Ubuntu, playable flash games in the "Get Started" app, DBS, ect...


enhanced fedora port has been canceled in favor of NITDebian (TBA)

Last edited by b-man; 2008-10-26 at 16:53.
 
Posts: 1,101 | Thanked: 1,184 times | Joined on Aug 2008 @ Spain
#7
- Nokia tablet sales so far have been relatively small, certainly nowhere near Nokia's phone sales (which are about 400 million units a year)
- Nokia's tablets have continued to be obscure niche items for three years now
Nokia has not marketed the tablets at all. I had to actively search for a device which fullfilled my requirements, and only thanks to google I found about the N810.
On the other hand, who doesn't know about the ipod and the iphone?
And it isn't that there is no market for those devices. I have seen people, not geeks but people with the most basic knowledge of computers, being turned away from the shiny ipod/iphone after showing them the N810 and its openness.
People doesn't like vendor lock-in. People likes to be able to do whatever they want with their devices.
I can install whatever I want in my N810, I can program it even in python, I have installed OpenOffice.org and use it on the road, just like a pocket computer. And I dream of being able to use it for presentations, projecting slides and videos in a big screen, everything I need in my pocket: the N810, the USB-VGA adaptor, and the still non-existent pocket projector. That surely will sell well.
 

The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to maacruz For This Useful Post:
allnameswereout's Avatar
Posts: 3,397 | Thanked: 1,212 times | Joined on Jul 2008 @ Netherlands
#8
Some observations:

Symbian has to take the 'good' aspects of competitors (such as Iphone) and implement these in their product. The vendor lock-in and lack of certain features/programs is not a + for some competitors; it is a -; and a + for Symbian & Co.

Qt on Symbian and Maemo makes portability easier. They already run on same architecture.

Maemo is a research project to understand which way Nokia wants to go with Symbian.

The NIT was not an always-on device while this is vital to some functionality. The N810WME is always-on due to WiMAX whereas the 'N900' will be always-on due to HS*PA.

Symbian is still a market leader and people still specifically make interfaces for Symbian.
__________________
Goosfraba! All text written by allnameswereout is public domain unless stated otherwise. Thank you for sharing your output!
 
tso's Avatar
Posts: 4,783 | Thanked: 1,253 times | Joined on Aug 2007 @ norway
#9
Originally Posted by b-man View Post
I know that this is a slightly off-topic and silly question but since Nokia is planning a fuew mager changes to the N900's hardware and software, do you think that both the N800 and N810 will be discontinued much like the N770 was when OS2007 came out? Since the N900 will likely have a more powerful prosesor and possibly a slightly different chipset allong with more powerful graphics (possibly OpenGL 2.0) and also a different camera.
imo, nokia has pretty much discontinued the N800 already...
 
fragos's Avatar
Posts: 900 | Thanked: 273 times | Joined on Aug 2008 @ Fresno CA USA
#10
I purchased an N810 instead of a smart phone because I the cellular carriers in the US continue to place restrictions on there operation and position things so that they are the recipients of all revenue from services of any kind. Even something simple like ring tones. Their solution is to have you pay more for 15 secs of sound than you pay for an entire song. They cripple the designed features of devices to eliminate or make difficult any DIY media. Apple won't permit iPhone applications that compete with those they've created. I'm through with closed devices. The N810 is totally open and remains that way because it isn't sold through carriers. The N810 even functions well as a VOIP phone. It even works with my Plantronics bluetooth head set. It's weak point as a phone is that it depends on WiFi. WiMax fixes that and for now voice messaging can fill those unconnected times for me. If I wanted to pay once again for Internet access with a cellular data plan I'd have full VOIP without any carrier imposed controls. The N810 overcomes the major problem with phones by eliminating the closed carrier. I see Nokia as a company with great vision verified by their success. The timing for an N900 is very good. The Android will pave they way for the open phone running Linux. The iPhone has already convinced the world that the best phone is a computer. Ubuntu is leading the charge to legitimize Linux for the average man. It's much to early to predict the death of the N series. With a SIM card an N900 is a ready made Android platform.
__________________
George Fragos
Internet Coach & Writer
Maemo Mapper HowTo
Personal Blog -- 3 Joe's Blog


N810 -- 5.2010.33-1
 

The Following User Says Thank You to fragos For This Useful Post:
Reply

Thread Tools

 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:38.