maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   News (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   It's official: N810 WiMAX announced (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=18593)

TheHMan 2008-04-02 04:41

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quick question about the device and what we already know about it. It seems to operate in the 2.5 ghz range which is actually compatible with most of Rogers existing Inukshuk network in Canada. This device is not locked down to a specific service provider or requires a contract to purchase the device right?

So technically, shouldn't I be able to head down to the US on a trip and pick one of these up and get Rogers to provide the Wimax service?

EDIT: Well I watched one of the videos on the main page, and it was hinted by that demo lady that I could probably do something like that here :D

Texrat 2008-04-02 09:44

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
You are correct: no device lockdown at all (EDIT: to carriers per se).

anidel 2008-04-02 11:03

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
AFAIK in Italy they are licensing WiMAX at frequencies of 3.4Ghz, while this WiMAX enabled tablet is set at 2.5Ghz.
So I suppose that us, in Italy at least, will be out of luck this round.
Unless Nokia comes out with a new EU version of the WiMAX version of the N810.

As far as I understand it the WiMAX has a pretty wide range of working frequencies, from 2Ghz up to 66Ghz.
The higher the frequency, the higher the bandwidth, the higher the battery consumption, the lower the penetration...right ?

Anyway, the choice of which frequency a WiMAX enabled device can talk on is a matter of the local government, as far as I can tell.
As usual EU and US looks like are following different paths.
EU is pushing bandwidth, while US penetration/power consumption.

In the end, the user pays for it.
If all I have written is true, then my WiMAX enabled device is already limited to only those countries that licensed the 3.4Ghz frequency and won't let me chat in the US.

Welcome to the real world, my dear.

speculatrix 2008-04-02 11:44

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
hmm, the 810-wimax spec says 2.5GHz, and the UK freq looks set to be 2.6GHz according to this:
http://news.zdnet.co.uk/communicatio...9287208,00.htm

so maybe we'll strike lucky after all.

SD69 2008-04-02 18:42

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheHMan (Post 163747)
Quick question about the device and what we already know about it. It seems to operate in the 2.5 ghz range which is actually compatible with most of Rogers existing Inukshuk network in Canada. This device is not locked down to a specific service provider or requires a contract to purchase the device right?

So technically, shouldn't I be able to head down to the US on a trip and pick one of these up and get Rogers to provide the Wimax service?

EDIT: Well I watched one of the videos on the main page, and it was hinted by that demo lady that I could probably do something like that here :D

The device is not locked down and you can buy it w/o a contract , but compatibility is the great unknown. This device was destined for XOHM before XOHM was even called XOHM. Remember compatibility is more than mere frequency,and also includes authentication mechanisms as well as access.

rnirnber 2008-04-02 18:51

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
are users going to have to pay for sprint's xohm service? is it going to be just another 50-60 dollar unlimited service deals like with sprint's evdo laptop card?

johnkzin 2008-04-02 19:03

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rnirnber (Post 164079)
are users going to have to pay for sprint's xohm service? is it going to be just another 50-60 dollar unlimited service deals like with sprint's evdo laptop card?


If you mean "have to" in the sense of "if you buy a N810WE you are automatically signing up for a service fee"? If it's anything like the GPS service on the N810 (nonWE) (almost pronounces like enui), then no. If you don't want to have WiMAX, and just want a black&amber N810, then you probably wont have to activate the WiMAX service and can use it just like the N810 (nonWE).

If you mean "have to" in the sense of "does WiMAX service cost money, or is it free with my N810WE"? ... I'm quite certain that Sprint doesn't offer XOHM on a charity or non-profit basis. So, yes, you'll have to pay for it in some fashion. :-)

SD69 2008-04-02 19:09

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by speculatrix (Post 163831)
hmm, the 810-wimax spec says 2.5GHz, and the UK freq looks set to be 2.6GHz according to this:
http://news.zdnet.co.uk/communicatio...9287208,00.htm

so maybe we'll strike lucky after all.

Sorry, close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades..

johnkzin 2008-04-02 19:13

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 164092)
Sorry, close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades..

yes, but the US has a tendency to "round off" about certain frequency statements. For example, we talk here about the 800MHz cellular band ... that is really at 850MHz.

I'm not saying that that's what's being done here, but it could be, and that would make "close" count for this too :-)

speculatrix 2008-04-02 21:46

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
I just checked and it appears that although OFCOM (office of communication) in the UK call our wimax band 2.6GHz, it's actually 2.5 to 2.692, so it looks as if the 810-we would work.

anidel 2008-04-02 21:59

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
no way 3.4Ghz can be considered close to 2.5Ghz....

RogerS 2008-04-02 22:26

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by anidel (Post 163822)
AFAIK in Italy they are licensing WiMAX at frequencies of 3.4Ghz, while this WiMAX enabled tablet is set at 2.5Ghz. So I suppose that us, in Italy at least, will be out of luck this round.

Note too that Nokia announced only that is was making the N810WE available in the United States, in areas where WiMAX is available.

rnirnber 2008-04-02 22:28

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnkzin (Post 164084)
If you mean "have to" in the sense of "if you buy a N810WE you are automatically signing up for a service fee"? If it's anything like the GPS service on the N810 (nonWE) (almost pronounces like enui), then no. If you don't want to have WiMAX, and just want a black&amber N810, then you probably wont have to activate the WiMAX service and can use it just like the N810 (nonWE).

If you mean "have to" in the sense of "does WiMAX service cost money, or is it free with my N810WE"? ... I'm quite certain that Sprint doesn't offer XOHM on a charity or non-profit basis. So, yes, you'll have to pay for it in some fashion. :-)

i meant "have to" in the second sense. i thought maybe there was a small chance it'd be free cuz sprint released their evdo service for free with amazon's kindle ebookreader device thingy, but then again the only thing the kindle could do was buy amazon ebooks.

Texrat 2008-04-02 22:35

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by anidel (Post 164190)
no way 3.4Ghz can be considered close to 2.5Ghz....

Did someone say it was? I just saw where 2.5 was said to be in the UK range... :confused:

bac522 2008-04-02 22:37

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
[QUOTE=anidel;163822]
Quote:

As far as I understand it the WiMAX has a pretty wide range of working frequencies, from 2Ghz up to 66Ghz.
The higher the frequency, the higher the bandwidth, the higher the battery consumption, the lower the penetration...right ?
No bandwidth is related to how much channel width and what modulating encoding scheme is used, so for sake of simplicity say you have a 100 MHz channel width you get 100 Mbps and 50 MHz channel you get 50 MHz. Higher bandwidth just has less ability to penetrate walls, which is why you can hear the bass at 22Hz through the floor, but not the tweeters at 20,000 Hz.

Quote:

Anyway, the choice of which frequency a WiMAX enabled device can talk on is a matter of the local government, as far as I can tell.
For the most part you're correct, I own a wireless service provider company and we've decided to use the 5.4GHz unlicensed frequency for deployment of WiMAX, but mostly as a last mile link. If one wanted to use the 810 on our network then Nokia would have to deploy it with a 5.4GHz WiMax RF chip.

Quote:

As usual EU and US looks like are following different paths.
EU is pushing bandwidth, while US penetration/power consumption.
I don't believe that to be the case, but I don't really follow the EU


Quote:

If all I have written is true, then my WiMAX enabled device is already limited to only those countries that licensed the 3.4Ghz frequency and won't let me chat in the US.
Bingo! But I think a lot of carriers are going to be in for a surprise as the unlicensed versions of WiMax carrier equipment starts appearing allowing for a greater range of competitor alternatives at much lower cost structures with out being tied into one carriers particular network. There was a time when one could only get voice from the telephony company, then VoIP came along and changed that whole game plan completely. The original goal when we started work on WiMax in the 802.16 forums was to have the same impact.

Benson 2008-04-02 23:06

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 164206)
Did someone say it was? I just saw where 2.5 was said to be in the UK range... :confused:

I think that was merely a statement of disappointment that no such discovery of workingness could be hoped for.

Benson 2008-04-02 23:08

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bac522 (Post 164211)
Higher bandwidth just has less ability to penetrate walls, which is why you can hear the bass at 22Hz through the floor, but not the tweeters at 20,000 Hz.

Here I thought that 20 kHz being above the audible range for people over 25 was the reason... :p

Seriously: You do mean higher frequency, not bandwidth, right?

SD69 2008-04-03 00:01

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rnirnber (Post 164199)
i thought maybe there was a small chance it'd be free cuz sprint released their evdo service for free with amazon's kindle ebookreader device thingy, but then again the only thing the kindle could do was buy amazon ebooks.

That's something different. Not free EV-DO, but free selected downloads via EV-DO. Back when Google was getting involved, there was some discussion of offering some minimal services via WiMax in an effort to try to increase new users. But XOHM has so many problems now, the freebies are the least of the issues.

bac522 2008-04-03 01:46

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Benson (Post 164240)
Here I thought that 20 kHz being above the audible range for people over 25 was the reason... :p

Seriously: You do mean higher frequency, not bandwidth, right?

Oops :D and I'm suppose to be an expert on RF...yes I meant frequency, thanks for catching that!

anidel 2008-04-03 07:16

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerS (Post 164197)
Note too that Nokia announced only that is was making the N810WE available in the United States, in areas where WiMAX is available.

Yes, I read that too.. that's why I wrote that we are not lucky "this round".
Waiting for the next one :)

anidel 2008-04-03 07:17

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 164206)
Did someone say it was? I just saw where 2.5 was said to be in the UK range... :confused:

Ehehe it was an ironic statement :D

anidel 2008-04-03 07:23

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Benson (Post 164240)
Here I thought that 20 kHz being above the audible range for people over 25 was the reason... :p

Seriously: You do mean higher frequency, not bandwidth, right?

ehehe
the house I am currently sleeping in has thick walls (being an old italian house), and my UMTS provider won't penetrate those walls, but the GPRS/EDGE signal does (and from a roaming partner).
So he's still right in my case :-p

The higher bandwidth provided by UMTS won't penetrate the walls. :D

johnkzin 2008-04-03 08:22

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rnirnber (Post 164199)
i meant "have to" in the second sense. i thought maybe there was a small chance it'd be free cuz sprint released their evdo service for free with amazon's kindle ebookreader device thingy, but then again the only thing the kindle could do was buy amazon ebooks.

And I'm sure Sprint gets a cut of those sales, in return for their EVDO "donation". There's no such built-in revenue stream for the N810 from which Sprint could take a piece of the pie.

acevid 2008-04-03 18:20

Sprint Xohm Launch Officially Delayed
 
http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/S...-Delayed-93257

looks the the WIMAX network intended for the WIMAX tablet is going to be delayed...

lhanneus 2008-04-17 15:00

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Will other than US Wimax version be made?

I leave in Brussel where we have "Clearwire" a pre-wimax provider. Clearwire operates at licensed 3.5GHz frequencies

Benson 2008-04-17 16:20

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
No such development has been announced, confirmed, or denied.

We can be pretty sure that it won't happen till after the US version, at any rate. It's quite possible, if the N810W is sufficiently successful, that Nokia expands into other popular bands; I don't know how widely used 3.5 GHz is; if it's Brussels only, not much chance; if it's 95% of Europe and half of China, it's pretty likely.

Texrat 2008-04-18 07:07

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
It's not just all about WiMAX: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/7348706.stm

sachin007 2008-04-18 07:56

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Its clear that nokia will support Lte rather then Wimax....... that suggests the lacklusture nokia interest and commitment to the n810 wme

Texrat 2008-04-18 08:29

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sachin007 (Post 171418)
Its clear that nokia will support Lte rather then Wimax....... that suggests the lacklusture nokia interest and commitment to the n810 wme

No, what's clear is that BOTH will be addressed.

If your doubt was correct, sachin, then NSN would not be making WiMAX base stations. ;)

vbrilon 2008-04-19 01:26

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sachin007 (Post 171418)
Ithat suggests the lacklusture nokia interest and commitment to the n810 wme

*blink* what? where did that one come from?

sachin007 2008-04-28 22:01

Re: It's official: N810 WiMAX announced
 
Hey texrat... How is your wimax testing going on?? I just wanted to ask you because we are in the same location and i am in a dilemma whether to save some cash for the n810 wme or just buy the n810 for now??


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:46.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8