maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   WiMax will live; Xohm dies (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=19853)

SD69 2008-05-07 11:41

WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
I have it on good authority that the Xohm network will be transferred to a multi-billion sort of joint venture headed by Clearwire. The venture includes Comcast, other CATV companies, Intel and Google. Apparently, the deal couldn't be finished in April but will be announced soon. I have no details on the pace of the network buildout or release date of N810 wme.

Texrat 2008-05-07 12:38

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
That's been in the news for weeks (speculative) and was confirmed by several sources yesterday.

But your subject is misleading-- Xohm isn't dead.

SD69 2008-05-07 12:54

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 178756)
That's been in the news for weeks (speculative) and was confirmed by several sources yesterday.

But your subject is misleading-- Xohm isn't dead.

OK, I didn't know it was confirmed.

And my understanding is that the WiMax service will not be sold under the Xohm brand, part of the nitty gritty of the deal

Johnx 2008-05-07 13:05

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Yeah, I saw that under the rumor category on gizmodo.com here. Their story links to articles in the new york times and wall street journal as well. I'm still reading through all the stuff, but it looks pretty legitimate to me. Just as long as I can one day get wimax service on a handheld linux box with a decent browser and a keyboard I'll be happy. I don't care who provides it. 8)

-John

fms 2008-05-07 13:39

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 178760)
And my understanding is that the WiMax service will not be sold under the Xohm brand, part of the nitty gritty of the deal

And such a good idea it is, too. As far as I see it, there isn't much difference between "Xohm" and "WTF" as a brand name.

mobiledivide 2008-05-07 13:43

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 178756)
That's been in the news for weeks (speculative) and was confirmed by several sources yesterday.

But your subject is misleading-- Xohm isn't dead.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phonescoop
Today Sprint Nextel and Clearwire Corporation announced that they will combine the two companies' WiMax businesses to create one national WiMax network. The new company will be called Clearwire and its goal will be to build out a high-speed wireless mobile WiMax network covering much of the U.S. Several other companies, including Comcast, Time Warner, Intel and Google, have contributed funds--totalling $3.2 billion--to this new company. Once the paperwork filings for the new company are complete, Sprint will own 51% of Clearwire, the former Clearwire investors will hold 27%, and the group of investing companies will own the remaining 22%

I believe this is what is in the news wire this morning so Xohm in a way is dead or at least renamed.

RogerS 2008-05-07 13:50

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobiledivide (Post 178775)
this is what is in the news wire... so Xohm in a way is dead or at least renamed.

I would say "recalled to life" -- to my thinking, this makes Sprint's WiMAX far less likely to fade away.

Whether we'll see Xohm in the ads or the effort is re-branded doesn't seem as significant as the finances promised in support of it.

Benson 2008-05-07 13:57

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Dead, renamed, what's the diff? (Provided one believes the right wierd reincarnation things, not much, I guess...)

Texrat 2008-05-07 14:29

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobiledivide (Post 178775)
I believe this is what is in the news wire this morning so Xohm in a way is dead or at least renamed.

Renamed works for me.

I'm not just being pedantic I don't think-- saying something is "dead" tends to start the kneejerk rumors flying by those who read quickly and incompletely. ;)

SD69 2008-05-07 18:04

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerS (Post 178779)
I would say "recalled to life" -- to my thinking, this makes Sprint's WiMAX far less likely to fade away.

Whether we'll see Xohm in the ads or the effort is re-branded doesn't seem as significant as the finances promised in support of it.

I think you guys (especially the rat) are missing the important point. Xohm was owned and controlled by Sprint. The new entity is a joint venture of which Sprint is merely one of several minority members - the JV is a new and DIFFERENT entity, controlled and managed in a different way. In particular, CATV companies are calling some of the shots now. This is far from a mere renaming or a rebranding.

Since the JV is a new entity, all of the vendor contracts with Xohm (Sprint) for network buildouts, devices, etc., may but do not NECESSARILY transfer to the new entity. In other words, they may (or may not) have gone "poof". The brand name is definitely not being transferred, and is dead. It is a good thing IMO because Xohm was already developing a bad reputation as hype, and it's good to let people know that Xohm is dead but another Wimax service will take its place.

Benson 2008-05-07 18:18

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Okay, renamed and half-sold-out; whatever. The trouble is, the headline makes it sound like Xohm, and consequentially, Sprint's WiMAX, is no longer coming, but someone, somewhere, is valiantly struggling on.

Perhaps a better title would have been:
Xohm is dead; long live Xohm!
Which, though rather non-literal, would have made the entire situation clear by inference.

Texrat 2008-05-07 19:04

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 178870)
I think you guys (especially the rat) are missing the important point.

Trust me, I am all too keenly aware of (and to an extent involved in) the important point, which I most assuredly did not miss.

At the risk of more axle-wrapping over semantics, I simply expressed concern over a subject wording that could lead to more hyperbolic rumor-mongering that does nothing but disrupt this place and feed the Engadget Monster. But I won't lose sleep over it. ;)

EDIT: okay, okay, "renamed" doesn't work... I like "absorbed" then. :D

deadmalc 2008-05-07 19:22

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
But the real question, when will it roll out world-wide esp. in the EU!

IcelandDreams 2008-05-07 19:33

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by deadmalc (Post 178903)
But the real question, when will it roll out world-wide esp. in the EU!

no no no, Canada gets it first. You Euros have other options for now, us poor slobs in Canuckistan have no wireless data services worth using. And to the south, well, that's a different planet.

:cool:

Texrat 2008-05-07 19:36

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IcelandDreams (Post 178909)
no no no, Canada gets it first. You Euros have other options for now, us poor slobs in Canuckistan have no wireless data services worth using.

Let them eat back bacon!

:p

SD69 2008-05-07 20:31

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 178893)
Trust me, I am all too keenly aware of (and to an extent involved in) the important point, which I most assuredly did not miss.

At the risk of more axle-wrapping over semantics, I simply expressed concern over a subject wording that could lead to more hyperbolic rumor-mongering that does nothing but disrupt this place and feed the Engadget Monster. But I won't lose sleep over it. ;)

EDIT: okay, okay, "renamed" doesn't work... I like "absorbed" then. :D

Om, fiercewireless and others besides the Engadget monster are describing it the same way as I did. Sprint's loss of managerial control and concessions to JV participants are also being reported now, such as the Wimax service being resold under Comcast and TW brands, etc.

Texrat 2008-05-07 20:39

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
*sigh*

Is this No Fun Wednesday or something?

:p

SD69 2008-05-07 21:32

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 178948)
*sigh*

Is this No Fun Wednesday or something?

:p

Whiny Wednesday I thought :p

deadmalc 2008-05-07 21:53

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
No offence to the US, but they don't have a mobile network yet ;-)
But seriously, I'm more worried that if they don't it will end up with the EU having some new tech and then them both costing a fortune for large data plans.

"no fun Wednesday", also known as mid-week depression

Texrat 2008-05-07 23:28

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
I think the consortium should have compromised and called the product ClearXohm.

:p

mullf 2008-05-07 23:53

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
> and concessions to JV participants are also being reported now, such as the Wimax service being resold under Comcast and TW brands, etc.

Well, duh, that's why the cable companies invested. Because they want to offer wired internet/wireless internet/and TV in a single package, just like the telecoms.

GeneralAntilles 2008-05-08 00:06

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 178948)
Is this No Fun Wednesday or something?

Every day is No Fun day on itT! Now GET BACK TO WORK!

F1shb0ne 2008-05-08 00:24

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Whatever the symantics, this probably spells more delays for WiMax roll-out while tactics are buttoned up. Nokia was no doubt counting on something happening sooner. Releasing N810WE in the absense of an imminent national roll-out is going to be a drag for them. They should really be on the cusp of realeasing the next piece of hardware if this finally gets momentum (by the end of 2008?). It's even possible that this delay is affecting their overall timeline for hardware roll-out.

RogerS 2008-05-08 00:24

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 178870)
I think you guys (especially the rat) are missing the important point. Xohm was owned and controlled by Sprint. The new entity is a joint venture of which Sprint is merely one of several minority members - the JV is a new and DIFFERENT entity, controlled and managed in a different way.

Actually, Sprint is 51 percent owner of the new company.

SD69 2008-05-08 01:12

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RogerS (Post 179050)
Actually, Sprint is 51 percent owner of the new company.

Yes, but they don't RUN the new company. The deal is quite a bit more complicated than comparing relative percentages of equity.

mullf 2008-05-08 02:14

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
I see no reason to preemptively worry. We'll see how things play out in the next few days.

Texrat 2008-05-08 02:20

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeneralAntilles (Post 179044)
Every day is No Fun day on itT! Now GET BACK TO WORK!

Yeah.

Kinda like last Thursday, where Work meant starting at 6:30 am, continuing to 11 pm, getting back up to check on a project with the Czech Republic at around 2:30 am, then 4:30 am, then 6 am.

If it wasn't for the 5 minutes I spent annoying people here, I'd have no fun at all! :p

SD69 2008-12-02 01:26

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

I think you guys (especially the rat) are missing the important point. Xohm was owned and controlled by Sprint. The new entity is a joint venture of which Sprint is merely one of several minority members - the JV is a new and DIFFERENT entity, controlled and managed in a different way. In particular, CATV companies are calling some of the shots now. This is far from a mere renaming or a rebranding.

Since the JV is a new entity, all of the vendor contracts with Xohm (Sprint) for network buildouts, devices, etc., may but do not NECESSARILY transfer to the new entity. In other words, they may (or may not) have gone "poof". The brand name is definitely not being transferred, and is dead.
Like I said six months ago, Xohm is dead. It's intended to be Clear WiMax, TimeWarner WiMax, etc.

It should be apparent now too that the XOHM vendor contracts are in peril...

http://www.reuters.com/article/techn...BrandChannel=0

heavyt 2008-12-02 03:10

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 246051)
Like I said six months ago, Xohm is dead. It's intended to be Clear WiMax, TimeWarner WiMax, etc.

It should be apparent now too that the XOHM vendor contracts are in peril...

http://www.reuters.com/article/techn...BrandChannel=0

¨Dead...vendor contracts are in peril...¨ That article never made such assumptions.

Texrat 2008-12-02 03:28

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
I have to go with Heavyt-- slowdown <> death.

SD69 2008-12-02 03:35

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Texrat (Post 246073)
I have to go with Heavyt-- slowdown <> death.

walking dead=Xohm brand
living in peril=vendor contracts with Xohm

mullf 2008-12-02 03:40

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 246076)
walking dead=Xohm brand
living in peril=vendor contracts with Xohm

The new company is 51% owned by Sprint. Also, Sprint is still operating as a company of its own. I would guess one or both companies would have legal troubles if they didn't fulfill the terms of a signed contract.

rjzak 2008-12-02 03:56

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Oh well. I much prefer the XOHM name to Clearwire. XOHM sounds 21st century while Clearwire sounds like a dot-com bust.

Either way, I'm sure they'll stay at 2.5 GHz since thats the range their hardware supports, and they'd be bloody fools and terrible businesspeople to change that. So, we as users and investors of this great WiMax technology should be fine. I shall miss the XOHM name if it goes (I don't think it will- a name change would confuse people, and thus, be a bloody stupid business move), the 2.5 GHz WiMax should survive, at least in the medium long term.

SD69 2008-12-02 04:07

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mullf (Post 246078)
The new company is 51% owned by Sprint. Also, Sprint is still operating as a company of its own. I would guess one or both companies would have legal troubles if they didn't fulfill the terms of a signed contract.

That doesn't mean what you think. Sprint doesn't have managerial control. I don't know whether Sprint is left with any legal trouble or not. (see iPCS)Since the new company is a JV, and did not acquire Sprint, they are not necessarily responsible for the Xohm contracts. See post #10.

mullf 2008-12-02 04:07

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
I read today that the new name of the service will be "Clear". Which is terrible. I say stick with XOHM.

mullf 2008-12-02 04:11

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
"Let’s Be Clear

The company also announced today that, while its company name will remain Clearwire, its new mobile WiMAX services will be branded Clear™. The Clear™ brand will apply to all new mobile WiMAX services to be offered by Clearwire in the U.S. and will be phased in to those markets where Clearwire offers pre-WiMAX services, as these existing markets are upgraded to mobile WiMAX technology.

In the coming months, the Clear brand will replace the XOHM service name previously used by Sprint Nextel in the Baltimore, Md. market. Clearwire expects current XOHM customers will not experience any impact as a result of the transaction, and they will continue to enjoy the current benefits of various notebook computing, portable multimedia and Internet devices, service plans and features.

In addition, the company unveiled a new marketing tagline, “Let’s Be Clear,” that will be used in conjunction with the new Clear service brand in upcoming market launches. The new marketing efforts will clearly communicate the service’s unprecedented combination of speed, mobility and simplicity."

http://newsroom.clearwire.com/phoeni...cle&ID=1231029

SD69 2008-12-02 04:17

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rjzak (Post 246084)
Either way, I'm sure they'll stay at 2.5 GHz since thats the range their hardware supports, and they'd be bloody fools and terrible businesspeople to change that. So, we as users and investors of this great WiMax technology should be fine. I shall miss the XOHM name if it goes (I don't think it will- a name change would confuse people, and thus, be a bloody stupid business move), the 2.5 GHz WiMax should survive, at least in the medium long term.

"if"?? (You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink...)

I thought of you DC area users today when i read this ("put on hold"). Good luck

http://www.muniwireless.com/2008/12/...a-possibility/

Texrat 2008-12-02 04:18

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rjzak (Post 246084)
Oh well. I much prefer the XOHM name to Clearwire. XOHM sounds 21st century while Clearwire sounds like a dot-com bust.

I'm with you 100%!

Plus Clearwire still has the word "wire" in it, which to me connotes a land connection. I hear Clearwire and I think "fiber".

Break "Xohm" into "X Ohm", and you get "no resistance". That resonates IMO.

Texrat 2008-12-02 04:20

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SD69 (Post 246093)
"if"?? (You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink...)

I thought of you DC area users today when i read this ("put on hold"). Good luck

http://www.muniwireless.com/2008/12/...a-possibility/

Just as the US has managed to thrive on supporting GSM and CDMA simultaneously (after some admitted rough times early on), I expect WiMAX and LTE can co-exist, too. Clearwire would be smart to invest in both... Nokia has. ;)

SD69 2008-12-02 04:28

Re: WiMax will live; Xohm dies
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mullf (Post 246091)
In addition, the company unveiled a new marketing tagline, “Let’s Be Clear,” that will be used in conjunction with the new Clear service brand in upcoming market launches. The new marketing efforts will clearly communicate the service’s unprecedented combination of speed, mobility and simplicity."

The deal only closed on friday, and the new website is already up.

www.clear.com

It's almost as if they decided to replace the Xohm brand with Clear (to me, it sounds like a Window cleaner) months ago

/sarcasm


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:19.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8