| 1   2     3   | Next
maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Accessories (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=17)
-   -   Best Screen protector for N900 ( again) (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=37284)

DeboX 2009-12-15 13:15

Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I know there are a few "screen protector" threads, and l apologise for setting up yet another one.

disclaimer aside, I have been sniffing around the N900 for a wee while now, and well ,like so many others, heard the rumours of the easily damaged screen on the N900. So the logical question is what's the best way to protect it, at the same time avoiding to degrade the general usability and feel of the screen. (stylus etc)

I have seen Zaggs invisible shield, and many claim that it's "the end all and be all "of screen protectors, while others claim that it degrades the feel of the screen and limits use of the stylus.

I know there are a ton of other screen protectors, but for a novice such as l , it is a wee bit complicated to get the bigger picture. Each seems to have issues, "this one has to be "manually" resized" and "that one has no holes for the proximity sensor" etc.

So suggestions? comments? And most importantly experiences...


BTW, I currently reside in Norway, so it's sort of imperative that what ever screen protector you suggest can be shipped to my humble abode here in the frozen north.

Kindest regards

DeBoX

ArmandHammer 2009-12-15 13:50

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I bought this one. around 20 bucks for 2. It also has holes for all the components and is pre cut. Also the screen feels exanctly the same as before I put it on. It doesnt make the screen rubbery feeling.
http://www.amazon.com/Lexerd-TrueVue...9&sr=8-2-spell

Fargus 2009-12-15 14:01

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Zagg works but does add some drag to the screen. It definately protects very well on everything I have used them for though. Takes about 10 mins to get used to with very slight additional pressure. I personally prefer it as the plain screen would occasionally be too sensitive for me and misinterpret gestures. Unfortunately might be a suck and see - at least with the Zagg you can protect the rest of the phone and peel the screen protector off if you don't like it.

darthpelo 2009-12-15 14:27

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I try durasec hightec, but makes the screen matte and "rubbery".
Now I have order brando, because many have advised me.

gravis86 2009-12-15 15:12

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
IMO, Clarivue makes some of the best. They stick on with static, and are not rubbery. But they don't make one for the N900 yet.

Flandry 2009-12-15 15:18

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I'm up for a screen protector, too, and found the combined case/screen protector/pouch thread overwhelming. I would be really nice if everyone that has tried more than one could state which they preferred, and why. I would prefer a protector with antireflective coating and more firm than sticky texture. I'm also curious if there are protectors that can act as complete weatherproofing cases, or if i'm better off getting a basic screen protector and a separate case for my frequent outdoor usage.

bltcool 2009-12-15 15:41

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
i have clearprotector on my and its pretty good, took at bit time to put it on but the sensitivity of the screen sure does not decrease

jsuggs 2009-12-15 15:47

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I tried the PhantomSkinz and so far I'm impressed. I'll admit that installation was not as easy as had hoped and it took a couple of days to lose the "haze" but now it is crystal clear, no adverse affects on sensitivity and it has GREATLY reduced the fingerprints on the screen.

tissot 2009-12-15 16:17

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flandry (Post 429086)
I'm up for a screen protector, too, and found the combined case/screen protector/pouch thread overwhelming. I would be really nice if everyone that has tried more than one could state which they preferred, and why. I would prefer a protector with antireflective coating and more firm than sticky texture. I'm also curious if there are protectors that can act as complete weatherproofing cases, or if i'm better off getting a basic screen protector and a separate case for my frequent outdoor usage.

I have tried Vikuiti DQC-160 screen protector and Invisible Shield screen protector. Vikuiti coating felt harder than the IS, but IS feels like it's more part of the device. Both vikuiti and IS are just as crystal clear.
I found getting the Vikuiti harder to put on the device. There where always some bubbles left while the IS is more complicated with the liquids and all i still find it better solution. It did take about 5 minutes more work than Vikuiti, but you will get it just right easier in the end imo. There where some microbubbles(like Zagg calls them) and one or two bigger ones. Microbubbles where gone after 24h and rest in 3 days.
My biggest concern with IS was that it would feel sticky, but in the end it was no problem. Coating has changed but you will not notice anything when actually using the device imho.

I don't find any reason to protect the whole device. It's done from very durable materials, no chrome like materials that would get scratched and Nokia thankfully even went for protecting the camera lens so yeah, can't find absolutely any reason to protect the whole device.

Nitchers 2009-12-15 16:23

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have this one it fits perfect and works great too.

http://www.protectionfilms24.com/art...900-27604.html

msa 2009-12-15 17:29

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
i'd say either m3 vikuiti if you only want to put something on the display or invisible shield if you go for fullbody-protection.
but those invisible shield make the device look "gum-like glossy" and anything but invisible, afaik.

m3 vikuiti is very stiff and "plasticcy" and virtually invisible.

eikido 2009-12-15 17:51

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Cool Nitchers.
Did you ever see/feel the difference between yours on and none on.

Eikido

eikido 2009-12-15 17:52

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
And i don't like IS because it feels like "rubber".

Eikido

wigglemeyer 2009-12-15 17:55

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jsuggs (Post 429116)
I tried the PhantomSkinz and so far I'm impressed. I'll admit that installation was not as easy as had hoped and it took a couple of days to lose the "haze" but now it is crystal clear, no adverse affects on sensitivity and it has GREATLY reduced the fingerprints on the screen.

I can second this; although I will add it definitely adds a rubbery feel and slightly decreases the sensitivity for me. There is a 33% off code floating aroung that will make this about 6 bucks shipped. I received this 2 days after I ordered it as they are based out of PHX.

texaslabrat 2009-12-15 17:59

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ArmandHammer (Post 428946)
I bought this one. around 20 bucks for 2. It also has holes for all the components and is pre cut. Also the screen feels exanctly the same as before I put it on. It doesnt make the screen rubbery feeling.
http://www.amazon.com/Lexerd-TrueVue...0884963&sr=8-1

wrong N900. Here's the appropriate link:
http://www.amazon.com/Lexerd-TrueVue...0899898&sr=1-2

R-R 2009-12-15 18:05

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have a phantomskinz on the screen and waiting for Zagg's full body shield for the rest of the device (ordered Phantomskinz as Zagg was backorder and wanted something for when i would receive the n900).

The PS is a bit hard to apply as even with water it doesn't slide once it touches the screen but i got it on almost alright and have one more protector left. It doesn't have any drag feeling and seems like a very good fit with 2 holes for sensors and 1 for the earphone.

I'll see what I'll be doing once i get the Zagg in my mailbox :)

youNit 2009-12-15 18:16

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I think I will be up to this combination:

ZAGG body armor + ClearProtector screen protector
Seems like the best method to me.
A body that adds rubbery feel, so your N900 wont slip of your hands, plus a screen protector that is said to have equal protecting abilities as ZAGG, but is less rubbery and does not degrade precision/feel.

msa 2009-12-15 18:25

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by youNit (Post 429309)
A body that adds rubbery feel, so your N900 wont slip of your hands, plus a screen protector that is said to have equal protecting abilities as ZAGG, but is less rubbery and does not degrade precision/feel.

thats why i like m3 protectors. they are smooth and stiff like plastic and not sticky like rubber.
for the case this might not be the worst solution, but i dont want that for the screen.

DeboX 2009-12-16 10:52

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
how is this one compared to zagg??

http://global.ebay.com/INVISIBLE_Nok...427215667/item

bornsavage 2009-12-16 12:30

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have a Zagg full body on the N900 as I am a clumsy oaf. I do not see a notiecable difference with the touchscreen with/without the stylus. So I like it.

DeboX 2009-12-21 08:42

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
No one has anything mroe to add???

angelove 2009-12-21 09:05

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitchers (Post 429171)
I have this one it fits perfect and works great too.

http://www.protectionfilms24.com/art...900-27604.html

does it affect in anyway the brightness or contrast of the screen? thanks

val580 2009-12-21 10:38

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
the arm200 is no good for the screen , the touch sensation is different and it adds a kind of rubber effect on the screen. avoid it.

Rushmore 2009-12-22 14:25

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have wasted $16 so far on two protectors:

1. The one linked on this site for 50% off that requires soapy water. The application was problematic for me.

2. I bought one from eBay that did not require water and installed easy and fit great, but had a mirror surface that distorted the image if you viewed the screen in any angle and also was not very clear then. (yes, I removed both films)

The eBay one would have been perfect without the mirror surface.

Fargus 2009-12-22 14:36

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by tissot (Post 429165)
...
I don't find any reason to protect the whole device. It's done from very durable materials, no chrome like materials that would get scratched and Nokia thankfully even went for protecting the camera lens so yeah, can't find absolutely any reason to protect the whole device.

i found that the original materials can be a tad slippery if not holding the phone firmly whereas the InvisibleShield on the back stops it slipping when you aren't paying attention or have cold hands.

bonerp 2009-12-22 14:43

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
i received a pack of 7 from ebay UK this week but they dont have a hole in for the earpiece doh - cant hear!!! Well designed I'd say - not.

cools 2009-12-22 15:19

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by val580 (Post 436204)
the arm200 is no good for the screen , the touch sensation is different and it adds a kind of rubber effect on the screen. avoid it.

I got an ARMR200 to replace my invisibleSHIELD, and it's exactly the opposite of what you've described. It's smooth and non-tacky, whereas the IS gave a rubbery effect.

It's a non-glossy, anti-glare surface that loves fingerprints - but I've used a similar hard plastic protector for years on my Clie and it never got scratched or worn so I'm confident it'll protect the screen correctly.

eikido 2009-12-22 18:31

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
that is why you should've bought the
Vikuiti™ DQC-160
What i did:)

406NotAcceptable 2009-12-22 19:03

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I manually installed a diy invisible armour, it feels rubbery and was a pain to put on the N900, but keeps the screen nice.

Clayton 2009-12-22 19:07

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gravis86 (Post 429076)
IMO, Clarivue makes some of the best. They stick on with static, and are not rubbery. But they don't make one for the N900 yet.

I bought one friday.

http://www.clarivue.com/nokia-n900-s...protector.html

Tiase 2009-12-22 19:07

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Ok, so the conclusion is? <_<

Would like to know which one is the "general" best, as it's nice to use and isn't rubbery and stuff.

My Nokia n900 should be arriving tomorrow morning, and i would like to know what screenprotecter i should use in order to protect its screen, but also so it's sensivity dosnt go down and stuff. : /


EDIT:
Ah, the one above seems nice, but what does it mean with anti-glare and ultra glare?

Svengalis 2009-12-22 19:26

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I highly recommend Phantom Skinz. Surface quality is just right and the optical clarity is excellent.

They include two protectors in each order so you have two chances to get the installation just right. :)

Price is less than $7 after their holiday discount.

Clayton 2009-12-22 19:27

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiase (Post 437918)
Ok, so the conclusion is? <_<

Would like to know which one is the "general" best, as it's nice to use and isn't rubbery and stuff.

My Nokia n900 should be arriving tomorrow morning, and i would like to know what screenprotecter i should use in order to protect its screen, but also so it's sensivity dosnt go down and stuff. : /


EDIT:
Ah, the one above seems nice, but what does it mean with anti-glare and ultra glare?

I'm assuming anti-glare reduces glare from the light sources but at the expense of some clarity.

I ordered ultra-clear.

Brunorange 2009-12-22 23:48

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cools (Post 437624)
I got an ARMR200 to replace my invisibleSHIELD, and it's exactly the opposite of what you've described. It's smooth and non-tacky, whereas the IS gave a rubbery effect.

It's a non-glossy, anti-glare surface that loves fingerprints - but I've used a similar hard plastic protector for years on my Clie and it never got scratched or worn so I'm confident it'll protect the screen correctly.

Exactly! I also started with the InvisiShield and first of all it is about 2-3 mm too long so it didn't fit... AND it had a very rubbery non slip surface where as the ARMR200 is smooth and more like the original screen... I must say I dont feel the sensitivity of the screen gets reduced much as my Device reacts very snappy and efficiently with the Vikuti ARMR200 on, which btw fits perfectly. :)

Tiase 2009-12-23 00:23

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Svengalis (Post 437950)
I highly recommend Phantom Skinz. Surface quality is just right and the optical clarity is excellent.

They include two protectors in each order so you have two chances to get the installation just right. :)

Price is less than $7 after their holiday discount.

Will the feel be just like on the screen?
Cause i want a screen protector that feels smooth( i asume thats hwo the screen will feel) and still shows the colors nicely, and there are so many out there that it's confusing D:

jandmdickerson 2009-12-23 00:46

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by val580 (Post 436204)
the arm200 is no good for the screen , the touch sensation is different and it adds a kind of rubber effect on the screen. avoid it.

Yes I agree avoid arm200 (I am currently using) go for the DQC-160. The arm200 is fuzzy looking thru it and makes loud paper noises when touched.

lukehall 2009-12-23 01:52

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have been using the IS from Zagg since last Saturday and find it works nicely. It did feel rubbery at first (and still does to an extent) but does not feel too bad now.

zdravko 2009-12-23 20:29

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I have tried both the Vikuti ARMR200 and the Vikuti DQC-160. Was very disappointed by both and would advise anyone to look elsewhere. The ARMR200 installed perfect but its quality quickly deteriorated. It was also a magnet for fingerprints. After complaining and e-mailing a picture to protectionfilms24.com, they offered to send me the DQC-160. The material is much better (almost no fingerprits), however the protector does not install perfect as noted by others here -I was left with 5 bubbles on the rims which for me is unacceptable...

I will most likely order the clear protector ~ 15USD which my very clumsy friend installed perfect (soapy method).

cddiede 2009-12-23 20:48

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lukehall (Post 438475)
I have been using the IS from Zagg since last Saturday and find it works nicely. It did feel rubbery at first (and still does to an extent) but does not feel too bad now.

I just installed my Zagg IS last night on the N900 and I'm loving it.

Other cheap protectors without a cutout for the phone speaker made it almost impossible to hear callers without going to speakerphone, bu the Zagg is really custom cut for the N900.

While it does make it a bit more difficult to use dragging motions with the stylus, it REALLY cuts down on the fingerprints that get transferred to the screen when you choose to not use the stylus.

This has made casual, non-stylus, use of my N900 much more pleasant.

digittante 2009-12-23 21:11

Re: Best Screen protector for N900 ( again)
 
I bought the Vikuti ARMR200 and found it un-satisfactory:
  1. It was near-perfect & smooth on 1st application
  2. My 2nd attempt to install it (to correct 1 dot imperfection) made it worse
  3. It attracts & displays so many fingerprints the display becomes cloudy
  4. It creates a slightly fuzzy distortion of the underlying screen
  5. It was expensive for only 1-in-the-pack

Size-wise, it fit perfectly, and it is thick/protective.

I'll probably try the Clarivue next which is half the price, and comes 2-in-a-pack.


| 1   2     3   | Next
All times are GMT. The time now is 17:49.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8