Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Maybe I'm wrong on this but here's my take...

Harmattan can be called MeeGo 1 for all I care, as long as Harmattan devices can be upgraded to the fully integrated MeeGo 2.

I hate to bring up the subject of device upgrades, but if the illusion is given that Harmattan *is* "MeeGo" (albeit with DEB packaging etc.) then it's a nonsense to release a different and technically incompatible MeeGo (with RPM packaging) only for those Harmattan users to discover they weren't actually running the real deal after all, and can't upgrade to the real deal either.

If a Harmattan upgrade path is built into the MeeGo plan then Harmattan could be based on a Windows kernel and nobody should care - it's only a transitional and temporary step in order to get to the promised land: MeeGo.

If the intention is for Harmattan to have a life beyond MeeGo then it would be wrong to confuse matters by referring to Harmattan as "MeeGo" because it's not MeeGo.

However if Harmattan is meant to be replaced by MeeGo - and users *can* replace Harmattan with MeeGo - then I would see no problem in blurring the distinction and allow both to be called MeeGo (perhaps v1 and v2...) and the sooner Harmattan and even Maemo is forgotten, the better.

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Yes, the issue is with Harmattan (and Moblin). Only Nokia can (un)brand Harmattan. MeeGo 1.0 as a result of a *finished* Moblin+Maemo merger I understand. QGil in this very thread said a month ago:

So far so good. But as time went by, both Maemo 6 and Moblin 2.2 picked up on the MeeGo moniker, so it's no longer just the result or successor that is called MeeGo. Maemo 6 is now MeeGo / Harmattan, and worse yet, moblin folks refer to Moblin 2.2 simply as MeeGo, which translates the above statement to MeeGo / Harmattan and MeeGo merge and have a successor called MeeGo. That can't be right... Harmattan and Moblin 2.2 as sort of ProtoMeeGo are okay, but pushing them under a MeeGo 1.0 umbrella will be a stretch no matter how you do it (being both better and worse ways of communicating this to people not interested in details, just general compatibility and upgrades).

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

I think the confusion arise from a confusing (fast changing) market. Cellphone are not what they use to be and people have come to expect more computer-like feature from them (see any FUD thread on tmo).

If I remember correctly even Google surprised a lot of people when they announced their Chrome OS. Why another OS when you already have Android ? I believe it is because right now we have "book sized internet portal" (netbook) and "pocket sized internet portal" (smartphone).

Nokia and Intel are just trying to merge the two worlds (duh !). So yeah, Maemo + Moblin = MeeGo on some device that is half smartphone and half notebook. I am not speaking of the next Harmattan device here. The one after, after that.

For now we will have to live with the (marketing created) confusion. In my opinion they should keep Maemo branding for smartphone and Moblin branding for netbook.

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Point of order:

"Simple" requests to rename (sub) forums should not be made in posts in the subforums themselves, they should be made in posts in the community subforum whose function is precisely "Website and community discussion".

You explained why the text Maemo 6 should be dropped from the forum's name and this makes sense. You explained why Harmattan is still valid. And that makes sense. You then asked to attach the text Meego which appears to be the new name of the operating system brand to the name of Harmattan which is an OS *version*. in which case it should not have included the "/" character just like there is no "/" between Maemo and 4 or Maemo and 5.

Is Meego like Windows or Windows 7?
Is Meego like Ubuntu or Ubuntu Karmic Koala?
Is Meego like Mac OS X or is it Mac OS X Snow Leopard?

Hm..bad example. But Apple gets away with a lot of stuff Nokia can't.

Personally I think the forum should have been renamed
"Maemo 6/Harmattan/Nokia ancestor of Meego"

where one could ask questions like "how to convert rpm's to deb's

We could also have created a subforum under the OS forum called

"Moblin 2/Intel ancestor of Meego" where we could ask questions like "how to convert deb's to rpm's?"

Finally we could create yet another subforum "Meego 1/Adaptable Alex" or whatever "A" word or combination of words you want to use. In this forum we could ask questions like "WHEN IT IS COMING!!!?!?!11!1" :) (typos added for humor)

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Btw is Harmattan/MeeGo release date still May like it was said in the 2009 Maemo event?

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Interesting question tissot. Would be interesting if they're still on track with Harmattan ;)

(And if not, we could start a speculation thread about the Harmattan SDK release date...)

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Don't you just love speculations... -.-

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

That's what keeps man alive. ;)

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Huh ? Harmattan is 2H2010, unless you refer to the Harmattan alpha SDK. We might see MeeGo 1.0, though i'm not sure if it will also not sport a 'beta' or 'alpha' moniker (and no, that one is still not for end-users).

Re: Renaming "Maemo 6" to MeeGo / Harmattan
 

Precisely yesterday I was thinking that this thread about naming could be de-sticked.

Posts #145 and following are a different topic,please move to a new thread.