maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Nokia N900 (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=44)
-   -   would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade? (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=46640)

zwer 2010-05-23 09:21

Re: would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade?
 
That would be a real downgrade. And, unfortunately, if rumors are true, the next Maemo/MeeGo device will sport both of those, which is precisely the reason I won't buy it (plus no QWERTY kb, which is even bigger of a deal breaker).

I'd never trade the precission of a resistive touchscreen for some gimicky multitouch, and N900s touchscreen is almost as sensitive as cap. screens. I would, however, pay for the Stantum resistive touchscreen update.

As for AMOLED, battery savings are minimal, while you loose the ability to read anything on the screen in a direct sunlight/strong light source, and mobile devices are mobile precisely for the reason to be able to use them when outside...

Rocketman 2010-05-23 09:58

Re: would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade?
 
I too feel that capacitive touch-screens have become too much of a buzz-word and not enough people understand the trade-offs. I have been extremely unhappy with every capacitive touchscreen phone I've tried for any period of time. I've used a lot of resistive panel devices with which I've had problems as well, particularly with calibration issues, dead zones, etc., but I've never had a problem with a resistive panel on a Nokia device.

I use a lot of applications that require greater precision than fat fingers can provide. These are not simple cases where a UI redesign would solve the problemm either. The inability to use a conventional stylus, fingernail, etc. with capacitive screens is an absolute deal-killer for me. The few capacitive styli available, such as the Pogo stick are bad jokes that provide scarcely any better precision than a finger.

Multi-touch on a phone sized device is largely a gimmick, with few usability benefits and a lot of downsides. The situation is different on an Ipad or tabletop size.

fmo 2010-05-23 10:21

Re: would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade?
 
If you want to know why Resistive touchscreens are better, just have a look at the MyPaint thread in Multimedia and try doing the same on a Capacitive screen

maxximuscool 2010-05-23 10:32

Re: would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade?
 
all i want is multi-TOUCH for gaming and zooming. Other than that i don't care

msa 2010-05-23 10:42

Re: would you pay for amoled & capacitive touch upgrade?
 
i wouldnt pay for amoled, i already did expect it on the n900. even my old 300 euro-phone had amoled (samsung s8000)

multitouch with capacitive screen i dont really want. i'm just nota big fan of the "handling" these kind of screens provide. although multitouch would be nice.
what happened to multitouch on resistive screens anyway? i remember seeing a video showing perfectly working multitouch on resistive screens.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:45.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8