maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Competitors (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=63654)

jerra 2010-10-11 07:19

After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
First off, this post is meant to be constructive.

I have owned a lot of Nokia GSM phones since 1994. Two GSM phones has been other brands, Samsung and Motorola but only for a few weeks because I simply didn't like them. I don't remember the models but it was a long time ago.

Well I have been using my N900 since it's launch and it has been a good phone. Been using it like a computer almost.
My N97 before that was fun for a few weeks because of the touch screen but other than that the phone was downright bad. Sluggish and crappy from start to end. (and I paid 724 euros for that :confused:)

I was demonstrated a HTC Desire and spent the weekend reading on about Android and what functions there are. In Android I found everything I need, calendar/contacts synchronisation, email, maps, Flash 10.1 and more. I've been so into Nokia I've never even considered anything else up until recently. Just proved to myself how important a familiar brand can be.

Looking back at my N97 and N900 it now feels like I paid for these phones to be some kind of beta hardware tester. N900 has been on the market for a long time considering the lifecycle of today's hardware and still not full support with Nokia's own applications.
Reading reviews of the N8 there are hints of slow UI reponse. History repeating itself. Reading some Nokia bloggers it seems they are pushing it as it was a high-end DSLR solution... (?) Totally shifting focus from the functions that really makes a smart-phone.

I really hope Meego will be a success story and that it will help Nokia advance and once again be the smarter choice for demanding users.

NvyUs 2010-10-11 07:21

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
good for you not like anyone cares

jerra 2010-10-11 07:32

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NvyUs (Post 838166)
good for you not like anyone cares

Right on the money considering Nokias strategies from the last years.

rickysio 2010-10-11 07:45

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Enjoy your stay in Spydroid land.

johnel 2010-10-11 07:58

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
I like the flexibility of the n900. You can pretty much install anything you like.
E.g. I use Python and Django is installed on the n900 too. There is also Easy Debian - I bought a combined bluetooth keyboard and trackpad and now for me the n900 is a "proper" portable computer.

Quite frankly, I don't care who makes a device like this. If Nokia produce something similar again then I may upgrade. If Intel or Microsoft (unlikely) produce something like the n900 then I will quite happily jump ship.

I don't care who manufacturers my "phone" as long as it can meet my requirements of the n900.

In fact I would go back to two separate devices if I got something like this: Pandora

I like Android but I am paranoid about my privacy and also Linux software is difficult to port over (no glib).

And Flash can kiss my hairy a*se!

NvyUs 2010-10-11 08:04

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
This site is not nokia why should we bothered
you make 1 post a week over last 12 months on average and then post this crap
why should we care we have read many like it.
Your opening line is "this is constructive" when you know full well it will turn into the other 100 like it.
I see nothing constructive about you post at all.

jerra 2010-10-11 08:08

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnel (Post 838189)
I like the flexibility of the n900. You can pretty much install anything you like.

Yes although I am not that into Linux with all the various things people seems to install. I understand that the real techies really appreciate what you can install into it.
I've kept myself to Extras-testing at the lowest. No devel.

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnel (Post 838189)
In fact I would go back to two separate devices if I got something like this: Pandora

That sure looks fun. Gonna have to read more about it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnel (Post 838189)
I like Android but I am paranoid about my privacy and also Linux software is difficult to port over (no glib).

That I will have to examine a bit more.

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnel (Post 838189)
And Flash can kiss my hairy a*se!

Yes well *ss-kissing or not its out there en-masse and there are no getting around it. It has started getting to me, "Please download the latest version...." messages when browsing. Really annoying.

jerra 2010-10-11 08:12

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NvyUs (Post 838191)
I see nothing constructive about you post at all.

Your (constructive) opinion has been duly noted skipper.

I would say without hesitation that Maemo and Nokia are quite closely related. :rolleyes:

jaimex2 2010-10-11 08:14

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NvyUs (Post 838166)
good for you not like anyone cares

Oh, but I do care.

NvyUs 2010-10-11 08:32

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jerra (Post 838197)
Your (constructive) opinion has been duly noted skipper.

I would say without hesitation that Maemo and Nokia are quite closely related. :rolleyes:

your correct but this site is no longer controlled by NOKIA and talk.maemo.org is not Nokia Maemo
try going to Nokia support discussion forum they have their official Maemo forum there :rolleyes:

Turkishflavor 2010-10-11 08:35

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
who the F**** cares what you are doing?

JonWW 2010-10-11 08:44

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Well goodbye.
Shame you felt the need, like so many other attention seekers to tell us that you hate Nokia, now run along quietly and buy your new device, and don't forget to slag Nokia off to the shop assistant when you buy your Android.
Oh, one other thing, if the N900 is more than you can handle, there is new firmware out for your N97 which finaly makes it run quicker and gives you free maps :)

jerra 2010-10-11 08:53

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JonWW (Post 838216)
... like so many other attention seekers...

? After using Nokia phones for 16 yrs, yes I do feel I have something to say.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonWW (Post 838216)
...that you hate Nokia...

What?? Are you like 11yrs old and slightly r e t a r d ed ?

Looking at the responses from all these "don't give a **** bye bye" I cannot but conclude there seems to be an eerie feeling out there that things are not what they should be (or have been).

Have you noticed that I am from Finland? Nokia is really important for our economy.

vivmak 2010-10-11 09:06

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jerra (Post 838163)
First off, this post is meant to be constructive.

I have owned a lot of Nokia GSM phones since 1994. Two GSM phones has been other brands, Samsung and Motorola but only for a few weeks because I simply didn't like them. I don't remember the models but it was a long time ago.

Well I have been using my N900 since it's launch and it has been a good phone. Been using it like a computer almost.
My N97 before that was fun for a few weeks because of the touch screen but other than that the phone was downright bad. Sluggish and crappy from start to end. (and I paid 724 euros for that :confused:)

I was demonstrated a HTC Desire and spent the weekend reading on about Android and what functions there are. In Android I found everything I need, calendar/contacts synchronisation, email, maps, Flash 10.1 and more. I've been so into Nokia I've never even considered anything else up until recently. Just proved to myself how important a familiar brand can be.

Looking back at my N97 and N900 it now feels like I paid for these phones to be some kind of beta hardware tester. N900 has been on the market for a long time considering the lifecycle of today's hardware and still not full support with Nokia's own applications.
Reading reviews of the N8 there are hints of slow UI reponse. History repeating itself. Reading some Nokia bloggers it seems they are pushing it as it was a high-end DSLR solution... (?) Totally shifting focus from the functions that really makes a smart-phone.

I really hope Meego will be a success story and that it will help Nokia advance and once again be the smarter choice for demanding users.

I have come across many colleagues and friends who have given up on Nokia and are moving to Iphone 4.... reason is simple that it is simple to use and has most of the apps already built ! I visit each day on this website in the hope that there will be a new app that I could use, so far there have been many, thanks to the community developers but few from Nokia stable.

Still hopefull that Nokia will release :
1. Ovi maps with T by T and vioce instructions
2. A voice dialling capability
3. Proper allignment of phone buttons when receiving calls ( it just switches itself from potrait ot landscape or vice versa depending upon how you take out the phone or screen simply stays locked !!!)
4. A proper email client.

and many more:)

jerra 2010-10-11 09:13

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vivmak (Post 838231)
...so far there have been many, thanks to the community developers...

Yes that is true. There are many apps that are really really good. fMMS and the modified Hildon desktop to name a few. After getting the first MMS on my N900 I was so happy I immediately made a donation.

Rauha 2010-10-11 09:28

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Hope you enjoy Android. It's a great OS with lot of good hardware.


As for the emotions in this thread, phones are just phones.

BatPenguin 2010-10-11 09:58

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jerra (Post 838221)
? After using Nokia phones for 16 yrs, yes I do feel I have something to say.


What?? Are you like 11yrs old and slightly r e t a r d ed ?

Looking at the responses from all these "don't give a **** bye bye" I cannot but conclude there seems to be an eerie feeling out there that things are not what they should be (or have been).

Have you noticed that I am from Finland? Nokia is really important for our economy.

Don't worry about the howling of the Nokia Defense Forces, people are tired of these threads since there are so many of these now. I don't understand why the ones who complain even read these things or come over just to click "Thanks" on whoever says "go away" in the most obnoxious way fastest...these threads exist in the Ubuntu forurms as well: "going back to Windows", "I'm getting a Mac"...I'm not interested in why people leave desktop Linux for Windows, so I never read those things. Similarly, I don't see why the complainers bother reading these at all here. Just skip them. All in all, this forum has gone downhill very fast. Now it's mostly active with threads like these and discussion about Nitdroid - "moving to Android without buying a new phone". Pretty sad state for Maemo.

For what it's worth, I understand what you're doing perfectly, including the Finnish guilt about moving away from Nokia :). I've too owned many Nokia devices, enjoyed them greatly (N810 especially, the E70 was a wonderful workhorse of a phone too back in less flashy times) and been very disappointed with current quality of Nokia's hardware and especially software. Hardware seems to be improving now at least, the horrible plastic toys that Nokia put out for several years seem to be gone...the new Symbian3 phones at least look better. But software...oh well. And yes, I'm from Finland too...with so many friends etc. working for Nokia that I can't help but feel guilty buying anything else but there's no way I can justify buying what I consider inferior devices when the alternatives (especially Android) are so good and, especially, constantly being improved on while Maemo is dead, Meego still just a fantasy and Symbian just plain ugly. If you have the money for a new Android or Iphone, it really makes sense to get one of those. For those who don't wanna send 400+ euros on phones, I always suggest the cheaper Nokias...Nokia Series40 phones are the best for value for money, anyway, by far of current phones, I think.

Anyway, If you haven't bought the Desire yet, I suggest you wait for the Desire Z: hardware keyboard and Android 2.2. The Hero has been a great phone but I miss a real keyboard, so I'm totally getting that when it's available...should be soon. Enjoy Android :)

jerra 2010-10-11 10:19

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BatPenguin (Post 838263)
...these threads exist in the Ubuntu forurms as well...

Yes I am too familiar with the infected Windows/Linux/<whatever> debates if they can be called debates. My intention here was only express my experience and thoughts on Nokia and Nokia phones. After all these years and $$$ spent on Nokia phones I do feel I have the right to spill out the beans.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BatPenguin (Post 838263)
...including the Finnish guilt about moving away from Nokia...

;) You managed to read between the lines. It does feel sad to realize that Nokia isn't up to par.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BatPenguin (Post 838263)
Anyway, If you haven't bought the Desire yet, I suggest you wait for the Desire Z: hardware keyboard and Android 2.2.

Yes that is the one I had on my mind. Curious though on how the scandinavian keyboard will be. Haven't found pictures of it.

geneven 2010-10-11 10:21

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NvyUs (Post 838211)
your correct but this site is no longer controlled by NOKIA and talk.maemo.org is not Nokia Maemo
try going to Nokia support discussion forum they have their official Maemo forum there :rolleyes:

I think that this site is still basically controlled by people who are largely controlled by Nokia. If it wasn't, it would go back to being called InternetTabletTalk, which would make it clear that Nokia doesn't get an automatic edge. I like my N900 but would much prefer a site that was neutral on the question of which device is best. That would eliminate needless fights by people who want to complain about Nokia and would make it much clearer that this isn't a Nokia site.

I bought five Nokia devices in a row, but that doesn't mean I'm owned by Nokia. I'd be much happier if the name of this site made it clear that this site is also not Nokia-owned. But I think there are serious interests at play here, monetary interests, that still give Nokia the inside track here. The dice are loaded.

BatPenguin 2010-10-11 10:29

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jerra (Post 838273)
Yes that is the one I had on my mind. Curious though on how the scandinavian keyboard will be. Haven't found pictures of it.

I found one the other week, this is from some Danish site:

http://www.connect-utb.com/images/st...3/nordtast.jpg


Looks good to me!

ysss 2010-10-11 10:47

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
@OP: Best of luck with the move.. as an (on-and-off) Nokia fan, I still root for them. It's unfortunate that Nokia products used to be an easy choice back then and now it's getting harder and harder to even justify a purchase of their best offering...

Quote:

Originally Posted by geneven (Post 838275)
I think that this site is still basically controlled by people who are largely controlled by Nokia. If it wasn't, it would go back to being called InternetTabletTalk, which would make it clear that Nokia doesn't get an automatic edge. I like my N900 but would much prefer a site that was neutral on the question of which device is best. That would eliminate needless fights by people who want to complain about Nokia and would make it much clearer that this isn't a Nokia site.

Are you serious, dude? Those users (even remotely) associated with Nokia are usually the level headed ones and they contribute the most with useful (tech, market, etc) informations and roadmaps.

I share somewhat similar feelings in regards to 'going back to ITT' though.

At the time, the change from ITT to TMO was a natural progression and it was positive. Now that 'TMO' moves on to MeeGo, I wonder about the continuity of this valued community.

Quote:

I bought five Nokia devices in a row, but that doesn't mean I'm owned by Nokia. I'd be much happier if the name of this site made it clear that this site is also not Nokia-owned. But I think there are serious interests at play here, monetary interests, that still give Nokia the inside track here. The dice are loaded.
I think you're overestimating some things there...

lattenwald 2010-10-11 11:08

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by NvyUs (Post 838166)
good for you not like anyone cares

Quoted for truth.

Metalfox 2010-10-11 11:11

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnel (Post 838189)
I like the flexibility of the n900. You can pretty much install anything you like.
E.g. I use Python and Django is installed on the n900 too. There is also Easy Debian - I bought a combined bluetooth keyboard and trackpad and now for me the n900 is a "proper" portable computer.

Quite frankly, I don't care who makes a device like this. If Nokia produce something similar again then I may upgrade. If Intel or Microsoft (unlikely) produce something like the n900 then I will quite happily jump ship.

I don't care who manufacturers my "phone" as long as it can meet my requirements of the n900.

In fact I would go back to two separate devices if I got something like this: Pandora

I like Android but I am paranoid about my privacy and also Linux software is difficult to port over (no glib).

And Flash can kiss my hairy a*se!


Kissing bumbum failed, you need to update your flash player to kiss bumbum.

twigleaf1976 2010-10-11 11:34

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Wow the jackals are out quick today.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rickysio (Post 838177)
Enjoy your stay in Spydroid land.

You think Nokia and PR 1.2 is any different? You log in to OVI? can see a history of all your downloaded products as you move through the very short menus? It isn't because of cookies that they know everything you have done on their software. You seriously think a hacked mod to stop PR1.2 from sending them data will change their attempts to monitor those that use their stuff?

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonWW (Post 838216)
Oh, one other thing, if the N900 is more than you can handle, there is new firmware out for your N97 which finaly makes it run quicker and gives you free maps :)

I think you proved the OP's point. 2 years after release (or there abouts) you now get firmware to make a crap phone run quicker.

But the N900 isn't more than I can handle, and I think it is a steaming pile of turd as well. I agree with the OP in that Nokia are releasing beta hardware phones and the N97, N900 and N8 are all in that category.

A persons hatred of the N900 or their intense dislike or long drawn out dismay at Nokia. Is not just because they might find some technical issues with it, that it somehow might be that the person is thick, or too stupid to understand the phone. But simply because it is a steaming pile of turd and doesn't do what they thought it should given the huge and over inflated price tag.

It might be a developers phone to most people on these forums but you point out on 'expansys.co.uk' where it says "...This is a developers phone", you can find the N900 listed under "mobile phones."

NokTokDaddy 2010-10-11 11:38

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
This site is largely polarised between the smartphone and linux-orientated factions.

When I first used my N900 I was adamant that it was a PHONE first and foremost - that was what it was sold as, and all this 'internet tablet/linux computer with a phone app' nonsense was just that - nonsense. To me at that time, anyway.

Since then, my position has shifted. N900 was my introduction to linux, to running any kind of command and to any kind of hacking (if I may be so bold as to associate myself with such activity).

I can now see that both factions are right: N900 can be a phone, although it has it's fair share of bugs and shortcomings. It can be a pocket linux computer, although why anyone would want to run full-scale desktop programs on such a small screen and with no mouse is quite beyond me.

So it is no surprise to me that when someone dares to criticise, let alone walk away from this community, they are lambasted by one side or the other.

It's just a shame that some individuals cannot engage in a constructive discourse as opposed to saying 'don't bump your arse as the door slams behind you on your way out'

crail 2010-10-11 11:53

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
wow you stayed out of devel, no wonder you got bored. ive had it open since release and never had a problem.

radiowc 2010-10-11 12:09

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Well, first... you don't have to stick to Nokia or whatever brands. Just get the phone that suite your daily needs. A lots of people claims they got the coolest phone... or the best phone in the World. Well, that only last couples of weeks or months or if you are luckily couple of years. lol.

Also, how many people really fully utilized all the functions they got on their phones before starting to look for another one. I'm sure some of the Apps/icons in your N900 or N97 are not even used or touch since it is there since day one you owned that phone.. LOL!

DavidWilliams312 2010-10-11 12:11

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jerra (Post 838163)
First off, this post is meant to be constructive.

I have owned a lot of Nokia GSM phones since 1994. Two GSM phones has been other brands, Samsung and Motorola but only for a few weeks because I simply didn't like them. I don't remember the models but it was a long time ago.

Well I have been using my N900 since it's launch and it has been a good phone. Been using it like a computer almost.
My N97 before that was fun for a few weeks because of the touch screen but other than that the phone was downright bad. Sluggish and crappy from start to end. (and I paid 724 euros for that :confused:)

I was demonstrated a HTC Desire and spent the weekend reading on about Android and what functions there are. In Android I found everything I need, calendar/contacts synchronisation, email, maps, Flash 10.1 and more. I've been so into Nokia I've never even considered anything else up until recently. Just proved to myself how important a familiar brand can be.

Looking back at my N97 and N900 it now feels like I paid for these phones to be some kind of beta hardware tester. N900 has been on the market for a long time considering the lifecycle of today's hardware and still not full support with Nokia's own applications.
Reading reviews of the N8 there are hints of slow UI reponse. History repeating itself. Reading some Nokia bloggers it seems they are pushing it as it was a high-end DSLR solution... (?) Totally shifting focus from the functions that really makes a smart-phone.

I really hope Meego will be a success story and that it will help Nokia advance and once again be the smarter choice for demanding users.

I feel exactly the same as Jerra. To hear that Nokia are abandoning Maemo is like a kick in the teeth and I'm now stuck with this white elephant "geek" phone on a 2 year contract...thanks a bunch Nokia!
I should have opted for an iphone or as Jerra says an Android driven device like an HTC Desire...Shame on you Nokia...and never again!!!

DavidWilliams312 2010-10-11 12:20

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by radiowc (Post 838330)
Well, first... you don't have to stick to Nokia or whatever brands. Just get the phone that suite your daily needs. A lots of people claims they got the coolest phone... or the best phone in the World. Well, that only last couples of weeks or months or if you are luckily couple of years. lol.

Also, how many people really fully utilized all the functions they got on their phones before starting to look for another one. I'm sure some of the Apps/icons in your N900 or N97 are not even used or touch since it is there since day one you owned that phone.. LOL!

On the contrary, I wish it did have basic functionality that a business grade phone should have like sync with Outlook, MSOffice application converter/reader...other phones have!

wmarone 2010-10-11 14:48

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Oooh oooh a Nokia/Maemo/people-who-like-the-n900 hate thread! Back and forth with the tit-for-tats "your vendor did something bad so that totally justifies my vendor doing something bad" and "omg what a terrible phone."

Why can't "I'm leaving you Nokia, and never coming back" threads like this get locked instantly, for the sake of our more reactionary audience?

Rauha 2010-10-11 15:22

Re: After 16yrs of Nokia phones going for other brand
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BatPenguin (Post 838279)
I found one the other week, this is from some Danish site:

http://www.connect-utb.com/images/st...3/nordtast.jpg


Looks good to me!

Waisting keys for having separate ones for Ä,Ö,Æ and Ø. Why didn't they put Ä/Æ and Ö/Ø on same keys. Then just let language settings (fin/swe and dk/no) set which ones are used.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:23.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8