Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

I would be very, very surprised if they did this but...

This is what Palm did in a similar situation. When they lost market leadership by not innovating the original PalmOS (I'm talking Garnet), they shipped Windows Mobile smartphones for a while to pay the bills.

The difference is Nokia may be losing high end market share but they are not hurting to pay the bills. I can't imagine them taking engineering and software resources away from Symbian, QT, and Meego so they can compete on the WP7 platform.

I call BS on this one...

Eldar is sitting in a bar somewhere laughing his butt off over this rumor.
David
David

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

I think there is a possibility that Elop, coming from a non-mobile background, thought that his first task coming to Nokia would be to get them on board the WP7 boat; because it is "shiny".

Hopefully his first weeks in the job showed him that such a move is not good, at all.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

Would be idiotic to bring Windows to Nokia.

Symbian^3 and MeeGo is the way.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

Yes, You live close to the headquarter. Please go there and tell them that before they do something stupid.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

eldar hasn't been in the headlines recently? well, this is one way to handle such issue especially when there are problems getting unreleased models from nokia for review.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

I have thought over 10 years also that noone should use MS Windows when there is Linux distributions which enable much much more; but still most of the relatives and people I know in RL use MS Windows, Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook.

Technically best does not always win. Think Amiga.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

Wrong apple first! :D

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

- Google would love Nokia to use Android

- Microsoft would love Nokia to use WP7

It would be weird if both Microsoft and Google representatives were not directly in contact with Nokia, trying to push their respective platforms.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

Nokia, has made 2 big mistake and one relay good move.

1) they dide'nt innovate and evolve Simpian fast enough and thought it would have a longer shelf life.

(good move) Meamo, was the perfect long term strategy for total market domination provided Simbian didn't become obsolete overnight and maemo could grow organically. This trajectory was a game change and the only reason I own an n810 and an n900. (there was defiantly talent in Nokias strategy team to try this.)

2) The second mistake is discovering the first mistake, and attempting to accelerate a good move to cover for it. Canning Maemo and switching gears to MeeGo thinking you getting ahead and springing off the back of Maemo. This mistake is so huge I believe they will loose the community, enthusiasts and the power users and eventualy the market.

so given the mistakes above WP7 looks like a good idea right now.
personal i cant see it succeeding either, but then it i am not on the parole and there success wasn't compromised by going with WP7 but more to the point dropping maemo, community.

Re: Eldar: Nokia and Microsoft Discussing WP7
 

Nokia isn't HTC.

HTC is a hardware company. They don't have any single software platform they want to promote. They do not care how many Android phones they sell - they only care about the total number of phones they sell. For them, it makes a lot of sense to diversify.

Nokia is a completely different story. As long as Nokia invests in developing and promoting Meego, they cannot "diversify". Selling win7 phones means selling less Meegos, which means - sabotaging their Meego effort.