maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   General (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=68675)

v13 2011-01-21 17:19

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
If I was going to place a bet here, I'd put it on Intel CPU. The reason is that MeeGo is a child of both Nokia and Intel and that Intel at some point in the future will release MeeGo devices. This means that Intel will expect to have available 3rd-party apps that were developed for MeeGo phones instantly, which is not possible if there is a different architecture.

See this thread for a related talk.

buchanmilne 2011-01-21 17:44

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LordNelson (Post 925383)
The SoCs inside the phones aren't just a ARM-Processor. There's usually a DSP too and maybe some hardware accelerators for video and other things.

The hardware enumeration from the boot log fragment showed a lot of non-typical-PC hardware (e.g. GPS on I2C bus).

Quote:

I don't think that a crappy 1,5 GHz Atom would decode 1080p in realtime at all
Depends more on the GPU, my Acer Revo R3610p (1.6GHz Atom 330 Dual Core) running XBMC plays 1080p h.264 with about 15% CPU utilisation. This is because the NVidia ION GPU it has has hardware-accelerated h.264 decoding.

Quote:

I rather guess that Nokia may bring out some MeeGo Tablet, that may have an Atom processor.
Of course, thus my comment that Nokia working on Atom-based development kits doesn't necessarily have anything to do with *handsets*, tablets are probably a better target with Atom?

Tedri Mark 2011-01-21 18:50

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ysss (Post 925354)
Sounds kind of fishy to me...
Something along the lines of "Let's make the ad so people think it's better than it is, not how truly good the thing is..."

Seen any Apple adverts recently?

In fact, any phone or computer adverts - just this morning I saw an advert for the intel core i5, which promised me that having one in my PC would enable me to experience images like never before...

Hmmmm...

Either that, or adverts will boast a feature common to lots of devices but maybe less known, so everyone will go 'Ooooh with the xPhone I can do xxxx' so I'm going to buy one of those instead of the yPhone'...

Quote:

Originally Posted by ysss (Post 925354)
This will lead to numerous cases of "I have this same intel sticker on my notebook/desktop, so why can't I run XXXXX program on this too??"

Does this happen with windows mobile or the iPhone? Actually what seems to happen is a 'mobile version' of PC software is made, which bears little resemblance to the 'full version'

"I've got photoshop on my phone!"

"No you haven't."

theonelaw 2011-01-21 19:01

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tedri Mark (Post 925619)
Seen any Apple adverts recently?

In fact, any phone or computer adverts - just this morning I saw an advert for the intel core i5, which promised me that having one in my PC would enable me to experience images like never before...

Hmmmm...

Either that, or adverts will boast a feature common to lots of devices but maybe less known, so everyone will go 'Ooooh with the xPhone I can do xxxx' so I'm going to buy one of those instead of the yPhone'...

>...<

"I've got photoshop on my phone!"

"No you haven't."

The Forer effect
Quote:

(also called the Barnum Effect after P.T. Barnum's observation that "we've got something for everyone") is the observation that individuals will give high accuracy ratings to descriptions of their personality that supposedly are tailored specifically for them, but are in fact vague and general enough to apply to a wide range of people. This effect can provide a partial explanation for the widespread acceptance of some beliefs and practices, such as astrology, fortune telling, Androids, iPhones, :D:D:D:D

Kenny1001 2011-01-21 22:48

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
can someone tell how the atom is different compared to snapdragon/hummingbird/tegra/orion?
Not having a dualcore in 2011, and been said it has dreamspecs...
so many questions(ram, gpu, EMMC, infraredport..will it be 3x powerfull compared to n900..)answers on 16feb

ysss 2011-01-21 22:58

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tedri Mark (Post 925619)
Seen any Apple adverts recently?

Quote one.

AFAIK they depend mostly on using images and positive interpretations of them by the audience rather than explicitly mentioning a 'promise'. You can't claim product misrepresentation when the customer is doing the interpretation not based on written claims.

Quote:

Either that, or adverts will boast a feature common to lots of devices but maybe less known, so everyone will go 'Ooooh with the xPhone I can do xxxx' so I'm going to buy one of those instead of the yPhone'...
This should be fine too, if the user is unfamiliar with said feature.

But I think you've missed the point of my post, which was made in reply to Andrew's.

mikecomputing 2011-01-21 23:13

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
latest rumors N900 will use VIA chipset...

retsaw 2011-01-21 23:37

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by v13 (Post 925538)
If I was going to place a bet here, I'd put it on Intel CPU. The reason is that MeeGo is a child of both Nokia and Intel and that Intel at some point in the future will release MeeGo devices. This means that Intel will expect to have available 3rd-party apps that were developed for MeeGo phones instantly, which is not possible if there is a different architecture.

Then why develop an ARM variant of Meego at all? Seems like a waste of resouces if they only intend to use it on x86 devices.

My prediction is that the N9 will be released late March and have an ARM CPU.

sexpapst 2011-01-21 23:43

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
I like x86. It's a nice pocket heater :)

volt 2011-01-22 00:34

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
if (x86 compatibility($N9)) {
port('VMWare');
}

mkaythanksplz.

ericsson 2011-01-22 00:54

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Keep in mind that Nokia already has announced at least one device with ST Ericsson U8500, dual ARM Cortex A9 1.2 GHz coming in 2011. MeeGo or Symbian, that is the question:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_ubl-vMLqw

Tedri Mark 2011-01-22 01:58

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ysss (Post 925732)
Quote one.

"This changes everything. Again."

Only thing it changed, it seemed was the definition of 'everything'

ysss 2011-01-22 07:52

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tedri Mark (Post 925804)
"This changes everything. Again."

Only thing it changed, it seemed was the definition of 'everything'

They're not quoting anything specific, let alone specs.

IE: on other products, did you always have to "let good times roll" or you always "couldn't beat that feeling", etc?

v13 2011-01-22 08:00

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 925786)
if (x86 compatibility($N9)) {
port('VMWare');
}

mkaythanksplz.

Or even better: Start using qemu (and perhaps KVM) and port wine.

Andrew_b 2011-01-22 08:11

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
In the UK advert for iPad, the voiceover stated:

"It's incredibly powerful"

The image on screen showed the device displaying some pie charts.

The point I was making was that in the advertising world of smoke and mirrors, having the Intel tag on a smartphone could go a long way.

shadowjk 2011-01-22 08:16

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mikecomputing (Post 924909)
PLEASE INTEL UNDERSTAND THIS :-( I DONT WANNA HAVE A FAN ON MY PHONE :-(

atm X86 platform is a bigjoke even on the desktop. I mean I have an MiniITX Dual Atom CPU and the fact that I need to have a fan and a big heatsink on it makes me SICK.

The desktop atom boards typically have fans on the gmch chip, not on the cpu. The desktop atoms (atleast Atom 330) have all power saving features disabled/absent.


It might be true that 1080p on singlecore Atom is impossible indeed, but Cortex A9 is equally helpless at 1080p. Not that it matters, an Omap3 or Omap4 would use the IVA/IVAHD for decoding, and atom would need something similar, like the previously mentioned ION on desktop.

Stskeeps 2011-01-22 09:29

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by retsaw (Post 925754)
Then why develop an ARM variant of Meego at all? Seems like a waste of resouces if they only intend to use it on x86 devices.

My prediction is that the N9 will be released late March and have an ARM CPU.

Because it's obvious there's a short and long term benefit in having same platform work on ARM and X86 and being able to build your company software stack on both and have it work on many different SoCs etc without difficulty. MeeGo gives companies freedom to select hardware and easily deploy on to new hardware.

=> Make many types of devices with different hardware specs with ease.

Tedri Mark 2011-01-22 09:42

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ysss (Post 925889)
They're not quoting anything specific, let alone specs.

IE: on other products, did you always have to "let good times roll" or you always "couldn't beat that feeling", etc?

Well, that tagline would be right at the bottom of the poster, after a list of the kind of uninnovative innovations i was talking avbouit before.

And yeah,all adverts do it, that's what we were saying.

one particularly annoying apple ad on the radio in the past couple of years had various people, with pc woes, whose lives were transformed into trouble free computung bliss when they bought a mac

"I had a digital camera, and nobody could tell me which cable i needed, then i got a mac, and it was all so much simpler"

Yeah mate, first of all where'd you get your camera with no cable from, and second, if nobody knows what lead you need to connect to a pc, it's not likely to be easier to find someone who knows how to connect it to a mac..
Anyways...
"THE POWER OF AN INTEL PROCESSOR IN YOUR POCKET"

You got to admit, that would shift a lot of units, and, with that sort of processing power, seeing a lot of desktop software ports wouldn't be entirely out of the question.

ericsson 2011-01-22 10:37

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tedri Mark (Post 925927)
Well, that tagline would be right at the bottom of the poster, after a list of the kind of uninnovative innovations i was talking avbouit before.

And yeah,all adverts do it, that's what we were saying.

one particularly annoying apple ad on the radio in the past couple of years had various people, with pc woes, whose lives were transformed into trouble free computung bliss when they bought a mac

"I had a digital camera, and nobody could tell me which cable i needed, then i got a mac, and it was all so much simpler"

Yeah mate, first of all where'd you get your camera with no cable from, and second, if nobody knows what lead you need to connect to a pc, it's not likely to be easier to find someone who knows how to connect it to a mac..
Anyways...
"THE POWER OF AN INTEL PROCESSOR IN YOUR POCKET"

You got to admit, that would shift a lot of units, and, with that sort of processing power, seeing a lot of desktop software ports wouldn't be entirely out of the question.

Intel is such a strong brand that no commercial is needed. It is enough with a small badge or picture or a snippet saying "Intel inside".

v13 2011-01-22 11:40

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ericsson (Post 925944)
Intel is such a strong brand that no commercial is needed. It is enough with a small badge or picture or a snippet saying "Intel inside".

In fact this is a really nice trick. Since current mobiles don't have a sticker saying "ARM inside", any kind of sticker will do the trick.

If you add a sticker saying "8086 inside" or "mips inside" it will be assumed to be a benefit (from people that don't know what '8086' is), when compared to current mobiles that don't say "XXX inside".

However, if there was such a sticker (ARM inside) then using another one (Intel inside) would not be such a benefit, unless it was accompanied with promotional videos.

My 0.02€

volt 2011-01-22 13:04

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by v13 (Post 925893)
Or even better: Start using qemu (and perhaps KVM) and port wine.

I think VMWare will get me longer than wine.

mikecomputing 2011-01-22 13:42

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by retsaw (Post 925754)
Then why develop an ARM variant of Meego at all? Seems like a waste of resouces if they only intend to use it on x86 devices.

My prediction is that the N9 will be released late March and have an ARM CPU.


there are not thaat many person inside nokia working with arm+meego port atleast not official. Most active on for example n900 port is stkeep non nokia employe...

mikecomputing 2011-01-22 13:44

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ericsson (Post 925793)
Keep in mind that Nokia already has announced at least one device with ST Ericsson U8500, dual ARM Cortex A9 1.2 GHz coming in 2011. MeeGo or Symbian, that is the question:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_ubl-vMLqw

yes with symbian.

tissot 2011-01-22 14:14

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rhastdan (Post 926058)
OK2.. this is for the real deal !

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jsFrW...eature=related

probably meego phone but sorry for the chinese i also didnt understand it.

... One of Aava's early protos.

theonelaw 2011-01-22 14:16

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Good News !!!



We have solved the power problem for Intel processors !!!!




http://www.atbatt.com/images_mlg/ra12-70sdg.jpg

:D:D:D:D:D

(better than a rick-roll, ya think ?)

gerbick 2011-01-22 15:04

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
And the perception of past gen Intel Atom processors running x86 continues.

Battery life on the N900 wasn't that great either.

ysss 2011-01-22 17:29

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tedri Mark (Post 925927)
Well, that tagline would be right at the bottom of the poster, after a list of the kind of uninnovative innovations i was talking avbouit before.

Subjective claims are subjective.

As long as they don't make any factual claims, then I think it's left to the reader to interpret the taglines\copywrites.

Quote:

And yeah,all adverts do it, that's what we were saying.
Yep, and I've been pointing out that unless the ad makes any specific and factual claims that they cannot live up to, then that's just the norm.

Quote:

Anyways...
"THE POWER OF AN INTEL PROCESSOR IN YOUR POCKET"

You got to admit, that would shift a lot of units, and, with that sort of processing power, seeing a lot of desktop software ports wouldn't be entirely out of the question.
These kind of things can generate hype for the initial wave of orders, but they can't sustain continuous sale unless the unit performs as well as the user's expectations. And using "Intel Inside" may raise their expectations to a level that Intel knows they can't deliver on this new platform (yet.)

So I don't think Intel is dumb enough to associate their "Intel Inside" tagline with their first wave of handphones.

slender 2011-01-22 17:35

Re: Rumor: N9 to have 1.2Ghz Atom
 
Sidenote about this intel inside sticker. Look at back of your N900 screen :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:27.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8