maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   Off Topic (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Let's talk Nokia stock. Really. (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=85965)

switch-hitter 2012-08-12 14:14

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1250919)
Wrong. WP raises the commercial bar. Android lowers it. The effect is with Android you have eventually to compete with price only. With WP you can compete with technology and innovation.

That is the complete opposite of reality.

Lumiaman 2012-08-12 15:04

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by switch-hitter (Post 1250551)
Tell us about your experience, what platforms did you develop for and what problems did you encounter with your Qt applications?

What does that have to do with price of rice in CHINA?

switch-hitter 2012-08-12 15:51

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250935)
What does that have to do with price of rice in CHINA?

You previously said:
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250935)
there is no way that Qt would have worked the way you guys think. there is no such thing as painless and seamless integration of different platforms.

I'm sure if you were experiencing problems creating cross-platform applications with Qt there are people here who would willingly help you overcome your difficulties.

I'm sure none of us could believe, even for a nano-second, that you would pontificate about a subject you have no real understanding of.

No, not our Lumiaman - he wouldn't talk out of his 4r53 would he?

So let us help you, a problem shared is a problem halved.

Lumiaman 2012-08-12 16:00

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by switch-hitter (Post 1250940)
You previously said:
I'm sure if you were experiencing problems creating cross-platform applications with Qt there are people here who would willingly help you overcome your difficulties.

I'm sure none of us could believe, even for a nano-second, that you would pontificate about a subject you have no real understanding of.

No, not our Lumiaman - he wouldn't talk out of his 4r53 would he?

So let us help you, a problem shared is a problem halved.

If Qt is such a great thing, why it didnt help NOKIA? Why it didnt help Maemo or Harmattan? Why did it take eons for them to put a product together? I will tell you why: NOKIA IS NOT A COMPETITIVE SOFTWARE COMPANY. PERIOD. They were good with simpler thing, and got overrun by more competitive companies.

switch-hitter 2012-08-12 17:21

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250946)
If Qt is such a great thing, why it didnt help NOKIA?

Mmm, that's a tricky one... could it be because NOKIA's Qt Creator IDE and QtQuick were still in Beta when Elop announced Symbian and MeeGo were deprecated? It's always a bit more difficult for software to make an impact before it's been released.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250946)
Why it didnt help Maemo or Harmattan?

It would have. Now it will help Android and iOS instead.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250946)
Why did it take eons for them to put a product together? I will tell you why: NOKIA IS NOT A COMPETITIVE SOFTWARE COMPANY. PERIOD. They were good with simpler thing, and got overrun by more competitive companies.

More competitive companies? Ah yes... Samsung. Of course, they do have a pedigree in software that NOKIA simply can't match don't they? I have to admit I can't think of their fabulous, incomparable software off the top of my head but I assume it must be great or you wouldn't be making that point.

number41 2012-08-12 21:41

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1250919)
Wrong. WP raises the commercial bar. Android lowers it. The effect is with Android you have eventually to compete with price only. With WP you can compete with technology and innovation.

WP not only raises the commercial bar, but it also enlargens your penis, gives you collegue degrees, gets you ripped in three weeks, and wins you green cards, right?

Suffices to say that MS has never competed on the basis of technology and innovation, most of it's "competing" resumes itself to legal manouvering, backroom deals, and putting the weight of its monopoly to good use. Let those cash hordes do their job, baby, that's how MS "competes".

Technology? There's nothing to compete with in said offering. Last I checked, it only runs on hardware MS selects, so an OEM can't select what hardware to implement it on.

Innovation? MS also has a tight grip on the code, no modifications allowed. What's there to innovate on, should Nokia release the next Lumias in a box of dry feces, so it matches the content inside? That would surely be a novelty..

While the situation of OEMs using others software is precisely the same, you seem to fail to acknowledge it due to being partial to WP. While android provides relative freedom for Oems AND users to modify the software, and provides Oems the freedom to run it in hardware of their choise, WP provides none of those, leaving no differentiation...

Come to think of it, it's the other way around... Android still has room for differentiation... On WP, given that both hardware and software are third-party controlled... That's where one can only compete on price.

But then again, much like WP won against an Android that beat it fair and square (in spite of WP cheating), WP is better "just because".

number41 2012-08-12 21:45

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250946)
If Qt is such a great thing, why it didnt help NOKIA? Why it didnt help Maemo or Harmattan? Why did it take eons for them to put a product together? I will tell you why: NOKIA IS NOT A COMPETITIVE SOFTWARE COMPANY. PERIOD. They were good with simpler thing, and got overrun by more competitive companies.

How many smartphones ran Qt, once again? Qt hasn't helped nokia because nokia took the asinine decision to not use in more than two phones, both of which were underpromoted.

Then the Chief Executioner Officer took the decision to give Qt the axe, and had the company shoot itself in the foot.

It's hard for a resource to help if you don't put it to use.

leon.anavi 2012-08-12 23:29

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lumiaman (Post 1250946)
If Qt is such a great thing, why it didnt help NOKIA?

The main idea behind Qt is to be platform independent. During the years Qt established as a leading platform independent C++ framework for desktops and it is very likely to have the same future for mobile devices.

No matter how good is a C++ framework it could not help marketing and sales guys :) Don't blame Qt for poor product management and marketing solutions.

volt 2012-08-13 09:54

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
For Nokia, Qt is no longer relevant, and what they sold off was not all of it. They bought but one Trolltech, but they've sold off Qt in two rounds.

As a software tool, Qt was always more relevant outside of Nokia anyway. To quote KDE.org:

Quote:

Why did KDE choose Qt?
Qt is the best GUI toolkit available for the UNIX platform. It would have been a grave mistake to build a project of the size and scope of KDE with anything else but the best.
So le's end the Qt failure disscussion here, because it makes y'all seem extremely context inaware. It's like "Petrol is a failure, it didn't help Tesla sell a single car!"

Back to the off topic topic:

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...93ad8908b6.png

One week view. No stock price trouble over the weekend. As usual, this is NOK1V, Helsinki, €.

Dave999 2012-08-13 10:30

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
why do you even discussing Qt here. Nokia don't need or care for Qt anymore, get over it. It's a relevant as if I buy a nokia device or not!

Stock gets a slow start today but I'm sure the will come around.

volt 2012-08-13 11:11

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
For the same reasons that we discuss other things Nokia sell out, because it's relevant to the company's assets, future, stock prices.

I would think that's why.

Dave999 2012-08-13 11:14

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 1251276)
For the same reasons that we discuss other things Nokia sell out, because it's relevant to the company's assets, future, stock prices.

I would think that's why.

Oh, Thats why :)

Can this do it for nokia?

Real or Fake...Nokia Phi :p

http://www.wpdang.com/wp-content/upl...WP8-RUMOR1.jpg

http://www.phonearena.com/news/Nokia...-board_id33148

mikecomputing 2012-08-13 20:24

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
for **** same i have added lumiaman on my ignore list aand still see his qutotes and now I probdly get banned but anyway shut the **** up lumiaman eather your are really a ***** or just plain stupid troll. Swhat he hell is your point? You don have clue what you talk about and its only damn ****ing bussines and marketing ******** that made company doing stupid decision. Ou are just a damn nokia fanboy who would follow what ****ing damn direction they go anywayx just ****ing conti ue buy stocks if you beleive bey sttragegy!!

personally I will not.

volt 2012-08-13 20:50

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
although i can't fault you for your thoughts, i think it's in your best interest with a bit of self moderation there, mike grabben.

Dave999 2012-08-13 21:33

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Way to many stars in that troll post.

On topic. Not so great day today for nokia stock :(

I wonder why?

specc 2012-08-14 05:06

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by number41 (Post 1251068)
WP not only raises the commercial bar, but it also enlargens your penis, gives you collegue degrees, gets you ripped in three weeks, and wins you green cards, right?

Suffices to say that MS has never competed on the basis of technology and innovation, most of it's "competing" resumes itself to legal manouvering, backroom deals, and putting the weight of its monopoly to good use. Let those cash hordes do their job, baby, that's how MS "competes".

Technology? There's nothing to compete with in said offering. Last I checked, it only runs on hardware MS selects, so an OEM can't select what hardware to implement it on.

Innovation? MS also has a tight grip on the code, no modifications allowed. What's there to innovate on, should Nokia release the next Lumias in a box of dry feces, so it matches the content inside? That would surely be a novelty..

While the situation of OEMs using others software is precisely the same, you seem to fail to acknowledge it due to being partial to WP. While android provides relative freedom for Oems AND users to modify the software, and provides Oems the freedom to run it in hardware of their choise, WP provides none of those, leaving no differentiation...

Come to think of it, it's the other way around... Android still has room for differentiation... On WP, given that both hardware and software are third-party controlled... That's where one can only compete on price.

But then again, much like WP won against an Android that beat it fair and square (in spite of WP cheating), WP is better "just because".

Grow up please. It's not about what is best using any of your favorite measuring sticks. Producing high quality HW is no less expensive for a Chinese company than a non-chinese company. The HW is produced in China regardless (or where ever the cost is smallest). With WP you have several sets of specs, lowest common denominator if you like, that (besides functionality and quality) also assures that it will be impossible for one company to just hack together some non branded HW and put WP on it.

At the same time there are no restrictions upward. The result is a competition about technology and features, not on price alone. Android has some of this, but not enough to create a lucerative market for the manufacturers. Samsung is the only manufacturer besides Huawei and ZTE that is able to make a profit. In a year Samsung will hit the wall. The economy is not sustainable, and there is nothing new or speculative about this. Google makes loads of profit, but nothing of that profit is redistributed to the HW manufacturers is another way of understanding this, there exist no mechanisms of doing it. Google will soon have to do something about this, or everything they have built will be gone. That is where Nexus an Motorola comes in. The only real Androids today are Nexus branded or is a Motorola. The others are copies.

ranbaxy 2012-08-14 06:04

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1251557)
In a year Samsung will hit the wall.

Let's see :o

volt 2012-08-14 06:27

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Asha, not Lumia, has been lifting Nokia's stock prices. http://www.bgr.com/2012/08/13/nokia-...ness-analysis/

danramos 2012-08-14 08:23

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 1251568)
Asha, not Lumia, has been lifting Nokia's stock prices. http://www.bgr.com/2012/08/13/nokia-...ness-analysis/

That is hilarious. :) ...And surprisingly commendable, I might add.

volt 2012-08-14 09:48

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
It's kinda like the market telling Nokia what they want, innit? You want to sell us WP? Here's what we'll do. We'll buy whatever else you have.

However Ashas success might be short lived. Other feature phone manufacturers, including Motorola, is dropping the entire segment because Android is falling in price.

volt 2012-08-14 10:00

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...4644f2a525.png

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...24bc0787ae.png

I honestly can't tell (see a trend) where this is going next.
As for what is causing Nokias fall, I'll point out from the news that the macro outlook for Europe is bad, entire market down. May be the primary reason today, may not.

Dave999 2012-08-14 12:04

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
The Euro crise?

volt 2012-08-15 09:09

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Surprise of the year: Elop wants to stick with Windows on Nokias phones. Yes, that's right, he's NOT jumping over to, say, Tizen, iOS, or Bada. Here's the shocking revelation:

http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/0...87E03G20120815

Anyway, my usual graph source seems to be down, so you'll have to have a look at i.e. google: https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp...L:NOK1V&ntsp=0

Dave999 2012-08-15 12:17

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Im not sure what is best from a nokia stock perspective. The anticipation for new devices or actuall an announcement of devices and delivery to shelfs?

volt 2012-08-15 13:35

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
My limited observations is that the only thing that is better than anticipation is when you deliver beyond expectations. :B But, I've got very limited data behind my observations.

Standard & Poor`s cuts Nokia's credit rating further from BB+ to BB-

specc 2012-08-15 13:41

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave999 (Post 1252121)
Im not sure what is best from a nokia stock perspective. The anticipation for new devices or actuall an announcement of devices and delivery to shelfs?

Who cares. No matter how you look at it, the stock must go up. Nokia has made it. We need to switch over to HTC and Samsung now to see if they are able to make it.

Dared 2012-08-15 14:12

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1252148)
Who cares. No matter how you look at it, the stock must go up. Nokia has made it. We need to switch over to HTC and Samsung now to see if they are able to make it.

Nope, they haven't made it - and their stock could easily go down. If the WP8 phones are a failure (or perceived as a failure) then their stock price will fall

Lumiaman 2012-08-15 14:15

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
I think the price is inching up in anticipation of September announcement, and I suspect the price will double by October

specc 2012-08-15 16:43

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Interesting reading.
http://www.1800pocketpc.com/why-we-l...81/#more-33781

volt 2012-08-16 07:24

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
But it isn't inching up.

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...a44780edbb.png

danramos 2012-08-16 10:34

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by volt (Post 1252476)

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-XNEWeGCQSr...-highfive1.jpg

Dared 2012-08-16 11:50

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1252236)

Haha, this is very funny *chuckles*

You do realise what this article screams, don't you....

That Windows Phone is missing a lot of features that are standard on other smart phones. You don't try to justify a decision for no reason ;)

You make me laugh

specc 2012-08-16 14:15

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dared (Post 1252564)
Haha, this is very funny *chuckles*

You do realise what this article screams, don't you....

That Windows Phone is missing a lot of features that are standard on other smart phones. You don't try to justify a decision for no reason ;)

You make me laugh

I didn't write that. I didn't make you laugh.

Dave999 2012-08-16 16:44

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by danramos (Post 1252536)

Hey Dan, Don't be *** like Elop! Nokia will survive...

http://a0.twimg.com/profile_images/1...eElopNokia.png

Great icon for n9 if you are working on a fart app :D

danramos 2012-08-16 22:50

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dave999 (Post 1252676)
Hey Dan, Don't be *** like Elop! Nokia will survive...

http://a0.twimg.com/profile_images/1...eElopNokia.png

Great icon for n9 if you are working on a fart app :D

http://forums.appleinsider.com/image...t/298/flags/LL

Dared 2012-08-16 23:31

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by specc (Post 1252627)
I didn't write that. I didn't make you laugh.

But you DID make me laugh!! You didn't write it, sure, but you fully believed it, which is even funnier

danramos 2012-08-16 23:36

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dared (Post 1252780)
But you DID make me laugh!! You didn't write it, sure, but you fully believed it, which is even funnier

http://farm2.staticflickr.com/1279/5...dd4ab3e946.jpg

specc 2012-08-17 12:11

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dared (Post 1252780)
But you DID make me laugh!! You didn't write it, sure, but you fully believed it, which is even funnier

WIth all respect dared dude (not much but still), I only gave a reference to an interesting reading with no comments what so ever. Everything you think I did or did not - is all in your imagination. It has nothing to do with me :)

Having said that, my N9 is in the drawer and my Lumia is in my hand :D It could have been the other way around, but there is a reason for everything. Not the reason your imagination tells you though.

volt 2012-08-17 13:34

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...a72067c611.png

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...70496153aa.png

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...5a5de8d367.png

http://bors.e24.no/e24/images/chart/...9af52f88a1.png

Starting to look like the worst has passed for now. (Now = until Windows Phone 8 is out)

specc 2012-08-17 17:54

Re: Let's talk Nokia stock. Really.
 
Take a look at HTC. 80% drop from June 2011.
http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=2...rce=undefined;

HTC is still going down. Nokia will survive, HTC is in big trouble.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:47.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8