maemo.org - Talk

maemo.org - Talk (https://talk.maemo.org/index.php)
-   SailfishOS (https://talk.maemo.org/forumdisplay.php?f=52)
-   -   Closing an application without killing main loop (https://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91947)

vranki 2013-12-04 17:11
Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Hi,

I'm writing an application which has to do dome network operations after user has closed the UI. Normally this is not possible, as the applications Qt main loop exits when closing the UI.

On Harmattan i found a workaround - re-starting the mainloop by calling QGuiApplication::exec(). This seems to crash on Sailfish.

The next workaround i tried to use is to create an event filter for the QGuiApplication and try to filter out the close event. QEvent::Close never happens, but QEvent::ApplicationDeactivate does. It can be used to prevent killing main loop, but unfortunately it also happens when user swipes the application to the background.

Any ideas on how can i accomplish this?

qwazix 2013-12-04 17:15
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
It's not exactly what you're asking, but you could create a daemon and control it from your application via dbus, so you don't have to work around the close event.

xerxes2 2013-12-04 17:22
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
I think what you want is the aboutToQuit signal which doesn't quit the mainloop until its callback returns.

http://qt-project.org/doc/qt-5.0/qtc...ml#aboutToQuit

pycage 2013-12-04 17:48
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
How about

Code:
app->setQuitOnLastWindowClosed(false);
in main.cpp?

javispedro 2013-12-04 17:48
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392595)
I'm writing an application which has to do dome network operations after user has closed the UI. Normally this is not possible, as the applications Qt main loop exits when closing the UI.
Actually the reason is that closing the last window generates a quit event. See http://qt-project.org/doc/qt-4.8/qap...dowClosed-prop

vranki 2013-12-04 19:36
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by pycage (Post 1392609)
Code:
app->setQuitOnLastWindowClosed(false);
Does not work - the main loop still exits. Same with Harmattan.

vranki 2013-12-04 19:47
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by xerxes2 (Post 1392602)
I think what you want is the aboutToQuit signal which doesn't quit the mainloop until its callback returns.

http://qt-project.org/doc/qt-5.0/qtc...ml#aboutToQuit
I created a aboutToQuit slot like this:

Code:
// Called when app about to quit - handle upsync & quitting
void ClientLogic::aboutToQuit() {
    qDebug() << Q_FUNC_INFO;
    QEventLoop eventLoop;
    eventLoop.exec();
}
On emulator quitting with this results in output:

Code:
virtual void ClientLogic::aboutToQuit()
The Wayland connection broke. Did the Wayland compositor die?
Killing all inferiors
Debugging has finished
Debugger just displays ??'s as stack trace so it's useless. The crash happens when eventLoop.exec() is called.

coderus 2013-12-04 19:54
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
why you need this? isnt better to rewrite logics?
set event filter, catch close event, do whatever.

xerxes2 2013-12-04 20:00
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392662)
I created a aboutToQuit slot like this:

Code:
// Called when app about to quit - handle upsync & quitting
void ClientLogic::aboutToQuit() {
    qDebug() << Q_FUNC_INFO;
    QEventLoop eventLoop;
    eventLoop.exec();
}
On emulator quitting with this results in output:

Code:
virtual void ClientLogic::aboutToQuit()
The Wayland connection broke. Did the Wayland compositor die?
Killing all inferiors
Debugging has finished
Debugger just displays ??'s as stack trace so it's useless. The crash happens when eventLoop.exec() is called.
Why are you calling eventLoop.exec()? You already has one mainloop running so just put your cleanup code in the aboutToQuit callback instead. The mainloop will not exit before the aboutToQuit callback returns. There was a bug in earlier sdk but in the latest version it works just fine.

http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php...ht=abouttoquit

vranki 2013-12-04 20:05
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by coderus (Post 1392666)
why you need this?
Because the application needs to synchronize it's state to a remote server when it is closed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by coderus (Post 1392666)
isnt better to rewrite logics?
set event filter, catch close event, do whatever.
I have been planning to make a separate daemon and ui, but due to limited time available i am not going to do this anytime soon.

I'd be even happy to write a patch to Qt or Sailfish itself if it is the only way and would be accepted into upstream.

coderus 2013-12-04 20:10
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
install event filter

vranki 2013-12-04 20:10
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by xerxes2 (Post 1392668)
Why are you calling eventLoop.exec()? You already has one mainloop running so just put your cleanup code in the aboutToQuit callback instead. The mainloop will not exit before the aboutToQuit callback returns. There was a bug in earlier sdk but in the latest version it works just fine.
The app is single threaded - everything happens in the main event loop. Everything (signals, slots, timers, networking) is frozen during aboutToQuit() call. That's why i'd need a second event loop to do processing without exiting aboutToQuit() in main thread.

vranki 2013-12-04 20:13
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by coderus (Post 1392673)
install event filter
..to which event in which object? As i wrote in the original post, i already tried it with no success.

xerxes2 2013-12-04 20:26
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392674)
The app is single threaded - everything happens in the main event loop. Everything (signals, slots, timers, networking) is frozen during aboutToQuit() call. That's why i'd need a second event loop to do processing without exiting aboutToQuit() in main thread.
Afaik you can only have one mainloop in both gtk and qt. I've never heard anything about having two.

vranki 2013-12-04 20:35
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
I think the reason for newly started main loop is in qwaylandeventthread.cpp line 37:

https://qt.gitorious.org/qt/qtwaylan...thread.cpp#L37

When app window is closed, the Wayland connection is broken and if something (in the new mainloop?) calls readWaylandEvents(), the process is killed.

coderus 2013-12-04 20:59
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
okay, event filtering seems not to work in emulator, try:
Code:
  app->connect( app, SIGNAL(lastWindowClosed()), app, SLOT(quit()) );
  app->connect( app, SIGNAL(aboutToQuit()), app, SLOT(quit()) );
and why not to use main class destructor for this purpose?

and
Code:
    int retVal = app->exec();
    qDebug() << "App exiting with code:" << QString::number(retVal);
    //you can do whatever here
    return retVal;

vranki 2013-12-04 21:28
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by coderus (Post 1392692)
and why not to use main class destructor for this purpose?

Code:
    //you can do whatever here
Signals, slots, networking, and all other asynchronous stuff does not work without a event loop. And i need those.

coderus 2013-12-04 21:32
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
what about other methods?

uvatbc 2013-12-05 00:04
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392658)
Does not work - the main loop still exits. Same with Harmattan.
Well thats surprising - I've been using setQuitOnLastWindowClosed in Maemo, Harmattan, Windows and desktop Linux at least for the last two years in qgvdial to achieve exactly what you need: Running the application in the background.

https://code.google.com/p/qgvdial/so...k/src/main.cpp

vranki 2013-12-05 12:19
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by uvatbc (Post 1392726)
Well thats surprising - I've been using setQuitOnLastWindowClosed in Maemo, Harmattan, Windows and desktop Linux at least for the last two years in qgvdial to achieve exactly what you need: Running the application in the background.

https://code.google.com/p/qgvdial/so...k/src/main.cpp
Ok, i think i'll need to create a simple test application for this issue.

vranki 2013-12-05 13:23
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
1 Attachment(s)
I attached a simple test application to this message. It creates a sailfish app and a timer printing a message every second. Before starting the app, it calls app->setQuitOnLastWindowClosed(false).

When you close the window, the mainloop exits and messages stop appearing.

Can anyone modify it so that after closing the window it still keeps running? Is current behavior a bug?

w00t 2013-12-05 13:48
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
This was a bug in the early SDK releases. Make sure you have the latest SDK.

See also: http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91595

Note that I have no problems running this on device.

vranki 2013-12-05 14:00
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by w00t (Post 1392870)
This was a bug in the early SDK releases. Make sure you have the latest SDK.
Maintenance tool reports no updates available.

Quote:
Originally Posted by w00t (Post 1392870)
See also: http://talk.maemo.org/showthread.php?t=91595

Note that I have no problems running this on device.
Could you elaborate a little.. What exactly is printed to console when you close the app by swiping down? Does the process really stay running?

w00t 2013-12-05 14:18
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392874)
Maintenance tool reports no updates available.
I don't know what to tell you, then. All I can say is that it's working fine, and I'm fairly sure we already fixed this :)

Quote:
Originally Posted by vranki (Post 1392874)
Could you elaborate a little.. What exactly is printed to console when you close the app by swiping down? Does the process really stay running?
The timer keeps running and printing. Yes.

ggabriel 2013-12-05 15:20
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by w00t (Post 1392881)
I don't know what to tell you, then. All I can say is that it's working fine, and I'm fairly sure we already fixed this :)
Is there any way to tell for certain the version of the SDK, aside from Alpha? (perhaps a git revision or similar?)

Alternatively, I suggest resintalling the SDK :-D

vranki 2013-12-06 11:01
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by ggabriel (Post 1392893)
Is there any way to tell for certain the version of the SDK, aside from Alpha? (perhaps a git revision or similar?)

Alternatively, I suggest resintalling the SDK :-D
I checked my SDK version (0.0.8-2) and Mer VM (2013.10.18-0) and they are the latest.


Can anyone give a third opinion how the app behaves on close?

vranki 2013-12-06 13:18
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
I just tested in SDK with another PC and the application still behaves incorrectly:

Code:
Timer (and main loop) is still alive
Timer (and main loop) is still alive
Timer (and main loop) is still alive
Timer (and main loop) is still alive
Timer (and main loop) is still alive
app->exec() exited - main loop stopped. This should NOT happen if user closed the window. But it does.
Remote application finished with exit code 0.

vranki 2013-12-18 15:54
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
The issue is now resolved. The bug was in still in latest SDK and was recently fixed by a SDK update. It also works correctly on device. Thanks for help!

mikecomputing 2013-12-22 16:58
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
No I am really confused.

Because in my case my app dont leave mainloop and in my case I want it to leave :confused:


Code:

    QGuiApplication *app = SailfishApp::application(argc, argv);
    app->setQuitOnLastWindowClosed(true);
    UDPManager *udp = new UDPManager();
    QQuickView *view = SailfishApp::createView();
    QObject::connect(app, SIGNAL(lastWindowClosed()), app, SLOT(quit()));
    view->rootContext()->setContextProperty("version", QString(VERSION));
    view->rootContext()->setContextProperty("udp", udp);
    view->setSource(QString("/usr/share/harbour-push2sail/qml/push2sail.qml"));
    view->showFullScreen();
    res = app->exec(); // stays here even when user swipe down and window closes
    delete app;
    delete udp;
    return res;

coderus 2013-12-22 18:23
Re: Closing an application without killing main loop
 
maybe just emulator bug. test on device and ignore emulator bug if arm build works okay :)


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:25.

vBulletin® Version 3.8.8