![]() |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Well, here is an good article, that answers a goodload of the speculations in this thread, including my own
http://techcrunch.com/2015/07/07/mob...r-of-business/ |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
With MeeGo and Nokia we saw that having both, the OS and hardware inhouse doesn't attract 3rd party manufacturers to license the OS, as they had to compete with the license giver in terms of hardware.
Jolla has always stated that licensing Sailfish OS and thus gaining market share has been the goal all the time. The design of the phone and the tablet hardware were a necessity to get Sailfish OS to a market where nobody was interested in licensing a so far unknown OS. Now that the situation has changed, and there is growing interest by 3rd party manufacturers to license Sailfish OS, it is just a logical next step to pursue that road. Imagine that, to have an Android-compatible system that does not force you to play by Google's rules. By the way, no one ever said, that Sailfish OS is to become more closed due to the licensing strategy. The opposite has been stated and been reiterated always. The press release sounds like the Mobile World Congress in Shanghai will be pretty interesting in terms of Jolla. @nieldk: I don't understand your reasoning. Do you want Jolla to succeed, or to remain in a niche that cannot sustain a company? |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
totally understand @NielDK!
You deserve better information. Reading the Techcrunch article gives the impression it has more info and is more on spot than jollas own announcement. Again very vague communication that forces to try reading between the lines and heats speculation... |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Even Nokia supported developers much more. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Just interesting quotes from article:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
Quote:
Anyway, Jolla has worked to run Sailfish OS on existing hardware such as the Nexus 5. The N9 and N950, however, became soon a deadend due to the lack of drivers, as there is no well performing Android hardware adaptation for the N9. Quote:
Not everybody needs Play Store when there are alternatives. I stopped using Play Store the day my only Google-ified Android device, the Nexus 7, was turned useless by Android 5.0. I don't miss Play Store, but I regret having bought apps there, because they are tied to Google devices. So, if an alternative store comes preinstalled, and it has good content, then why would someone need Play Store? Amazon IMHO has proven the opposite, and AFAIK the Kindle Fire Tablets and Fire TVs are not selling that badly. And there's no Play Store in China either, or is there by now? Quote:
Do not fear the opposite. Most non-UI stuff is already being developed in the open on github (under the Nemo Mobile disguise), and some UI stuff, such as the browser got opened, too. And it doesn't look like the (admittedly, slow) process of opening has ended yet. Quote:
At Jolla, OTOH, the developer support is given by the busy Sailfish OS developers themselves, sometimes in their spare time. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
With all that noise, just hope to see a FairPhone2 with sfos, that would be great!
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
In my humble opinion we need improve the OS and more native apps than new hardware.
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
Some sort of clarification about this from Jolla would be very welcome, as I can see a nontrivial number of contributors from the open source community, that are not satisfied with the current closed source mobile landscape and might be willing to help improve a truly open mobile OS. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
I think realistically Jolla are simply stuck in the middle of being completely open with the community, but at the same time don't want to constantly let down the community. Also if Sailfish OS becomes a seperate entity from Jolla then maybe they open source more to allow the community to speed up development. Its why libhybris was opened up wasn't it?(unless I've miss interpreted the blog) |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Wow... talk about your leap of faith. A company splits to ensure that the right people are placed in the right endeavors/channels and since it goes against your personal whims and expectations; it's a bad thing. No... in fact, it's the worst thing ever and you're going to leave.
All I see is that folks are speaking from a personal investment level and not from a company making moves in an ever-changing environment level. BRICS alone is a good move for Jolla. And that ensures that it will stay more open than Android and iOS. The hardware division split concerns me. But perhaps it's just to divert folks that would be useless in some areas and make them useful on some Jolla inspired/internal endeavors whereas Sailfish OS is now the push to be an alternative in some of the countries way too fed up with Google and Apple (or just America to be completely honest) and are embracing something that can seem more homegrown and ready faster than starting from scratch. I don't share any excitement on this. Nor do I have any insider information. But given how the game has changed since 2007; this might be a savvy move. Or it might not. Time will tell. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
I think they are all great people and if they were not, they wouldnt have gotten onboard the ship in the first place Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
This, unfortunately (in my opinion), is a quite normal way for Jolla to communicate. An open company as they claim they are, seems to be pretty closed (in my opninion) Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
^ that statement, believe it or not, is expressing my concern for their survival. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
What you call humanity work, most people would call resource allocation.
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Sadly, this reminds me of Palm's "burning platform" era, when they tried a lot of broken strategies. Including splitting into hardware and software companies.
Eventually, the software part got bought by some other company and the code was never to be seen again. The hardware company, ironically, ended up starting another operating system, which ended up being used on .. TVs? before finally disappearing, too. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
TLDR - there isn't really anything new here. Dunno why this statement specifically is what's worrying you. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
So Niel, you leave, then kickstarter then leave again? Your points are exaggerating and interpretative in a massive way, Jolla said they will cease device business, now they announce they continue device business... what is bad in that? That you put different departments in different companies is also risk management and maybe Nokia (or any other company) has their hands in it and Jolla protects SFOS from being bought and destroyed through device investments.
Jolla also announced that they will open more sources, looking at the bigger FOSS companies, they all make money from other companies, not from private users so sailfish-secure will probably their commercial piece in terms of FOSS, highly adapted security devices for specific company/government needs. There are companies out there doing that closed-source without you even knowing their name as they do not offer any consumer devices. I can go on and on fighting your misconduct, but here it is also coming down to 2075eur you got from the community and you quit before you even started, I don't ask for money, I do everything here voluntarily, use my savings to buy devices. If you are worth the shot you probably be in Jolla's developer program... so what hardware did you buy from those 2075eur? Which is 4 phones (including a full stack of TOHs incl TOHKBD) and 3 tablets btw... and will you donate them to the community as you are leaving now? |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
EDIT: I could be completely wrong though, so a clarification would be nice ;-) |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Antti Saarnio @ Jolla Pioneers Facebook group about 2h ago:
Quote:
Antti Saarnio Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
with TOH
...that sounds, like the next Phone could still have TOH. :eek::cool: |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
I was afraid it would be the first thing on the chopping block for new Sailfish OS devices - which would be a great shame! |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
What about asking to him on that facebook group whats about future of opening sailfish and How is related to licensing business? I find reasons exposed reasonable.
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
I hope the updated first post answers many questions targeted at me and my initiative regarding funding.
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
Cheer up, and do continue the good work you are all doing. |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Just asked on fb. Waiting For a reply but A.Saarni
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Can you please ask him to clarify his "TOH" comment too (see 2nd post on this page)
I can already predict the response, if there is one... :) |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Sure i can. Tell me what are Your questions
Otherwise if i Will be generical and vague i suppose official reply would sound Like "we are working on it.we ll share new info SOON ( copyright all rights reserved)" ahahhaah just joking |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
please ask him: Who is responsible for the Tablet? what part of the organization?
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
Probably that also means, there will be no more of that particular tablet. Or, it will afterwards, be handed over to the new device company (I guess they will 'buy' the rights to use the already designed tablet). |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
@itdoesntmatt About Jolla TOH, just ask them if it's def. on the table for a successor device, & for that matter; is a J2 def. on the table, or will it depend on investment/partners that the new co. can secure? |
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Quote:
link: http://jolla.com/wp-content/uploads/...2015_FINAL.PDF Quote:
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
And that's not all of it IIRC, there was a few more minor clarifications in the TechCrunch article too.
|
Re: So Long and Thanks for all the Fish
Asked. We ve just to wait For a reply
|
| All times are GMT. The time now is 07:57. |
vBulletin® Version 3.8.8