Thought I'd post a few pics for everyone. I used 2 coats of primer and 3 coats of "Textured Black" and "Flat White". They came out quite nicely, though I might sand down the white to get rid of a blemish.
I went with textured black because I hate slippery electronics, hopefully it will hold up in the long run with all the skin oils and such! Next thing we need to find is some replacement buttons, lol!
Thanks Texrat, couldn't have done this without your awesome contribution to the forum!
The closest thing I could find to what you're talking about is "Plasti-dip". Which could be found in Home Depot's (US Home Improvement chain). Other than that, I don't know, I've been trying to find this since I got my e816 Motorola Phone, same rubberized paint...feels cool.