Menu

Main Menu
Talk Get Daily Search

Member's Online

    User Name
    Password

    Possibly fake Nokia batteries - how unsafe are they really?

    Reply
    Page 2 of 3 | Prev |   1   2   3   | Next
    Karel Jansens | # 11 | 2007-08-30, 16:55 | Report

    Methinks the biggest risk is that the knockoffer fritzes up the overcharge protection circuitry in the battery.

    I mean, that's Kaboom! time.

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Texrat | # 12 | 2007-08-30, 16:58 | Report

    That's the biggest singular risk, but not the most common one (based on reports).

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    vees | # 13 | 2007-08-30, 17:36 | Report

    thanks for your reply. kind regards!

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Karel Jansens | # 14 | 2007-08-30, 19:15 | Report

    Originally Posted by Texrat View Post
    That's the biggest singular risk, but not the most common one (based on reports).
    Yeah, but think about it: If your phone/tablet explodes in your face, are you really going to report about it?

    I mean, I know about ouijah boards and stuff, but we're talking about sketchy communications at best...

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Texrat | # 15 | 2007-08-30, 19:49 | Report

    Good point. I'll ask my magic 8 ball...

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    vees | # 16 | 2007-08-30, 19:52 | Report

    right :-))

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    iball | # 17 | 2007-08-30, 23:03 | Report

    Originally Posted by Texrat View Post
    Good point. I'll ask my magic 8 ball...
    Well, I threw my chicken bones (gift from Leeroy Jenkins) and they said to stay away from fakie batteries.

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    geneven | # 18 | 2007-08-30, 23:19 | Report

    Not one person at this site has reported an exploding battery, and I'm sure lots of people have bought non-Nokia batteries here.

    Here's the difference between a Nokia and non-Nokia battery, as far as I know. The Nokia ones are probably manufactured in China, and sent to Nokia, which packages them with their products. The non-Nokia ones are probably manufactured in China, and are not packaged by Nokia. I wouldn't be a bit surprised to find that some non-Nokia batteries were produced in the same factory as the Nokia ones. Read up on Chinese manufacturing, it's quite interesting.

    The ones I have bought were a zillion times cheaper than Nokia, and for me they have worked great.

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Bernard | # 19 | 2007-08-31, 00:03 | Report

    I don't know about the tablet batteries but for the phones I used a lot of BL-5C batteries that were very cheap ( 1 or 2 euros, because no one bid on them on ebay ) and fake.
    They work ok. they don't explode or overheat or anything, but after a month or two they don't hold charge as well as they should. (about the same as my 14 month old, heavily used nokia battery that I wanted to replace) .
    My experience is that the official Nokia batteries last very much longer .

    I used two different no-name brands from different sellers, I had the same kind of experience with both.

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Texrat | # 20 | 2007-08-31, 00:13 | Report

    Originally Posted by Bernard View Post
    after a month or two they don't hold charge as well as they should. (about the same as my 14 month old, heavily used nokia battery that I wanted to replace) .
    My experience is that the official Nokia batteries last very much longer.
    Right, that's a common experience. Not to say it's 100%, because geneven is correct in what he says, too. Buyers just need to realize they're gambling, and decide for themselves if it's worth it or not.

    Edit | Forward | Quote | Quick Reply | Thanks

     
    Page 2 of 3 | Prev |   1   2   3   | Next
vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Normal Logout